Is the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program Ending? What Ohio Employers Should Know for 2027

Originally published September 16, 2026. Updated November 19, 2026.

The Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program is continuing. Medical Mutual of Ohio will replace UnitedHealthcare as the program’s administrator and stop-loss carrier on January 1, 2027. Employers who want to remain in the program need to select a new plan and complete the transition paperwork.

November update: We are now helping employers review their Medical Mutual proposals and prepare their submissions. Plan to submit your completed transition materials by December 15, 2026, and earlier whenever possible. Below, we explain what to gather, how to find your suggested replacement plan, and where to view benefit illustrations for all 15 plan options.

Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program transition to Medical Mutual for 2027

When an Ohio small business owner called me in September, her question was understandable: Is my health plan going away? Her company was enrolled in the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program, and she had received information indicating that something was changing.

At the time, there were still unanswered questions. We now have new plan designs, employer rate offerings, and instructions for completing the move to Medical Mutual.

What Is Changing with the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program?

The Ohio Chamber will continue sponsoring the self-funded multiple employer welfare arrangement, or MEWA. Medical Mutual will take over the administrative and stop-loss responsibilities currently performed by UnitedHealthcare.

The existing UnitedHealthcare-administered benefit plans expire December 31, 2026. Employers continuing in the program must choose their replacement coverage and complete the required application and enrollment steps for January 1.

That means reviewing new benefits, rates, provider access, and prescription coverage, as well as completing the paperwork.

What Do Ohio Chamber Employers Need to Submit?

As we help employers complete this transition, these are the items we are gathering for their Medical Mutual submissions:

  1. Completed employer master application. The employer completes and signs the new group application, even if the company is already participating in the Ohio Chamber program.
  2. Signed proposal or rate acceptance for the selected plan. Review the Medical Mutual options and sign the acceptance section for the plan your company chooses.
  3. Updated enrollment census and waiver information. Provide current information for employees enrolling in coverage and their covered dependents, along with the list of eligible employees waiving coverage. Use the current enrollment template supplied for your group.
  4. Ohio Chamber member number, if available. Include the company’s member number to help identify its membership. If you cannot locate your member number, contact us for help while you continue preparing the other materials.

The signed plan acceptance is one part of the submission. The employer application and updated enrollment information also need to be completed. Depending on the group’s circumstances, additional documents may be requested, including materials related to COBRA or continuation coverage.

Plan to submit your completed transition materials by December 15, 2026, following the instructions in your rate offering. Starting earlier allows more time to resolve questions and complete the setup.

Use the resource folder below to access the blank employer application, enrollment spreadsheet, and provider search instructions.

Open the Ohio Chamber Transition Forms and Provider Search Instructions

For enrollment updates, review the spreadsheet’s “Instructions-sold only” tab and complete the “census enrollment” and “waivers” tabs.

Download your own copies before entering information. The public folder is for blank resources only; completed applications and employee information should be returned securely.

Need Help Completing Your Ohio Chamber Transition?

If your company hasn’t received clear guidance—or you have a proposal in hand but aren’t sure what to do next—McCarthy Stevenot Agency can help.

We’re helping Ohio employers compare their Medical Mutual options, gather the required enrollment information, and work through the transition paperwork for January 1 coverage.

You don’t need to have the forms completed or a plan selected before contacting us. We can help you sort out the next steps and provide secure instructions for sharing your materials.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency or call 513-891-9888.

How Do You Find Your Suggested Medical Mutual Replacement Plan?

Your renewal packet includes a page titled Coverage Options with the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program. It appears on page four in the packets we are reviewing.

Find your current UnitedHealthcare plan ID in the right column, then look across to the suggested Medical Mutual plan in the left column. The table below reproduces those plan matches.

UnitedHealthcare-to-Medical Mutual Plan Matching Guide
Medical Mutual Plan Current UnitedHealthcare Plan ID
25-0-1000 EQ-ZX
2520-1000 EQ-ZD, EQ-ZL, EQ-ZT, EQ-ZU
25-0-2000 EQ-ZI, EQ-ZH
2520-2000 EQ-Y7, EQ-ZE, EQ-ZM, EQ-ZP, EQ-ZV
2520-3000 EQ-Y8, EQ-ZF, EQ-ZN, EQ-ZQ, EQ-ZW, EB-SJ
25-0-3500 EQ-ZJ, EQ-ZR, EQ-ZB
25-0-5000 EQ-Y9, EQ-ZK, EQ-ZC
2520-6000 EQ-ZA, EQ-ZG, EQ-ZO, EQ-ZS, EQ-ZY, EB-RW
HSA 3500/20% PD Rx* EQ-YM, EQ-YR, EQ-YX, EQ-Y2
HSA 5000/0% PD Rx* EQ-YN, EQ-YP, EQ-YQ, EQ-YS, EQ-YU, EQ-YY, EQ-Y3
HSA 7000/0% PD Rx* EQ-Y5, EQ-Y6, EQ-YO, EQ-YT, EQ-YV, EQ-YW, EQ-YZ, EQ-Y4
35-0-6500 Additional plan option
3520-7500 Additional plan option
HSA 3000/0% (aggregate) Additional plan option
HSA 8750/0% MMRx Additional plan option

* PD means post deductible. Source: Medical Mutual, Coverage Options with the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program (X12106-SMG 8.26).

If your current plan ID is not listed, the guide explains that Medical Mutual may not have received enough information to identify a recommended match. The available plan options remain open to you, and we can help identify the closest fit.

A suggested replacement is not necessarily an identical replacement, and you are not required to choose the suggested match. Compare the deductibles, coinsurance, out-of-pocket maximums, office visit benefits, prescriptions, and rates before deciding.

Once you choose a plan, sign the acceptance section for that plan’s rate offering. In the packets we are reviewing, the signature area appears below the quoted rates. Return the signed acceptance with the other required transition materials.

View the 2027 Medical Mutual Plan Benefit Illustrations

Medical Mutual offers 15 Ohio Chamber plan designs: 10 traditional copay plans and five Health Savings Account (HSA) compatible plans.

We have gathered the benefit illustrations for all 15 options in one folder. Use the Medical Mutual plan name from your proposal or the matching guide above to find the corresponding PDF.

View the 2027 Ohio Chamber Plan Benefit Illustrations

The folder opens in Google Drive and can be viewed without signing in. These documents outline benefits such as deductibles, office visits, hospital services, and prescription coverage. Your company’s rates are provided separately in its proposal.

These are illustrative benefit summaries, not the standardized Summary of Benefits and Coverage (SBC) documents or the complete plan contract. Refer to the applicable SBC and governing plan documents for additional details, limitations, and coverage terms.

What About Doctors, Hospitals and Prescription Drugs?

The new Ohio Chamber plans use Medical Mutual’s SuperMed provider network. Employees should check the physicians, specialists, hospitals, and facilities they expect to use.

For step-by-step help checking your doctors and hospitals, view the Medical Mutual provider search instructions (PDF). The guide explains how to search without logging in and select SuperMed PPO with Cigna PPO.

A provider’s participation in the current UnitedHealthcare network does not establish participation in the new network. Review the network for the specific plan and confirm with the provider when necessary.

Prescription drug benefits will be administered through Express Scripts. Employees who use maintenance medications, specialty drugs, mail-order prescriptions, or medications requiring prior authorization should review those arrangements before the transition.

Employees or dependents receiving ongoing treatment may qualify for transition-of-care accommodations. Examples can include cancer treatment, pregnancy-related care, or an upcoming medical procedure. Requests require Medical Mutual’s review and approval under the applicable requirements.

Raise provider, prescription, and ongoing-treatment questions early. That gives the employer, broker, providers, and Medical Mutual more time to address them before January 1.

Important Dates for Ohio Chamber Employers

  • December 1, 2026: Medical Mutual recommends accepting coverage and submitting completed implementation materials by this date to improve the likelihood of receiving identification cards before January 1.
  • December 15, 2026: Plan to have your completed employer transition package submitted by this date. Follow the submission requirements and any specific deadlines in your rate offering.
  • December 31, 2026: The existing UnitedHealthcare-administered benefit plans expire.
  • January 1, 2027: The new Medical Mutual-administered coverage takes effect for groups that complete the transition.

The Chamber’s public employer notice encourages completing enrollment by December 15. Medical Mutual also describes a December 1 through December 31 special open enrollment period for January 1 coverage, with January enrollment changes available for a February 1 effective date. Those employee enrollment windows should not be treated as an extension of the employer’s transition paperwork deadline.

Medical Mutual estimates approximately five to ten business days for implementation after receiving complete and accurate materials. Allow time for questions or corrections, and confirm that the submission has been received and any outstanding items have been resolved.

Employers should also confirm the length of their rate offer and their next renewal date, especially if their current plan does not have a January 1 anniversary.

Should Employers Compare Other Health Insurance Options?

The new Medical Mutual arrangement may work well for many participating employers. Choosing a replacement plan is also a reasonable time to compare the proposed benefits and rates with other available options.

Depending on the business, those alternatives might include another Ohio MEWA, a level-funded plan, an ACA-compliant small-group plan, or an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA).

An ICHRA allows an employer to establish a contribution toward employees’ qualifying individual health coverage. Other employers may find that a traditional group arrangement remains the better fit. The decision depends on costs, benefits, provider access, eligibility, and the needs of the employees.

For medically underwritten alternatives, completing or updating a health insurance prescreen can help establish which options are available and what they may cost. Completing a prescreen does not obligate an employer to change coverage.

We explain that process in our guide to health insurance prescreens for Ohio small businesses.

Keep the transition timetable in view while comparing alternatives. Establish a clear coverage plan for January 1, and obtain written confirmation of replacement coverage before canceling an existing arrangement.

Sources and Plan Resources

Editor’s note: This article was originally published September 16, 2026, updated October 15, 2026, and updated again November 19, 2026, to add practical submission guidance, the plan matching table, and access to the 2027 benefit illustrations. Follow the instructions in your group’s current rate offering and transition materials. Details remain subject to governing plan documents and subsequent program updates.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations, and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Related Resources