What Does an ICHRA Benchmark Actually Mean?

Ted Stevenot of McCarthy Stevenot Agency with Broker’s Desk headline, “What Does an ICHRA Benchmark Actually Mean?”

An ICHRA benchmark may help determine how much an employer contributes. It does not necessarily determine which health plan an employee buys.

Ted Stevenot of McCarthy Stevenot Agency with Broker’s Desk headline, “What Does an ICHRA Benchmark Actually Mean?”

I was recently comparing two ICHRA proposals for the same employer.

One proposal used a Bronze health plan as its ICHRA benchmark. The other used a Silver plan. One proposed paying a percentage of that benchmark. The contribution amounts varied by employee age.

At first glance, it looked like we were comparing different health plans.

We really weren’t.

We were comparing different methods for answering a much more basic question:

How much money should the employer make available to each employee?

Understanding that distinction makes ICHRA proposals much easier to evaluate.

An ICHRA benchmark is a measuring Stick

Suppose an employer wants to contribute toward employees’ individual health insurance premiums.

The employer could simply establish a flat allowance, such as $400 per month for every eligible employee.

But that creates an obvious issue.

Individual health insurance premiums vary substantially by age. A $400 contribution might cover most of the premium for a 25-year-old employee while covering much less for a 58-year-old employee.

Another approach is to choose a health plan as a benchmark and use its premium to establish the employer contribution.

For example, suppose the employer decides:

We will make available 75% of the premium for a particular benchmark plan.

Now assume that benchmark costs:

  • $300 per month for a 25-year-old employee
  • $700 per month for a 58-year-old employee

Using the same 75% formula, the employer would make $225 per month available to the 25-year-old and $525 per month available to the 58-year-old.

The employees receive different dollar amounts, but the employer is applying the same contribution philosophy to both.*

*Federal ICHRA rules generally require employees within the same class to be offered the arrangement on the same terms, but employers may vary the maximum allowance based on age and the number of covered dependents. Age-based variation is subject to a 3:1 limit between the oldest and youngest participants. U.S. Department of Labor / IRS

But the employee doesn’t necessarily buy the benchmark plan

This is where the terminology can become confusing.

Suppose our 58-year-old employee has a $700 benchmark premium and the employer establishes the ICHRA allowance at 75% of that amount.

The employee now has a maximum monthly ICHRA allowance of:

$525

That does not necessarily mean the employee has to purchase the $700 benchmark plan.

Perhaps the employee finds a Bronze plan for $600.

The $525 allowance can be applied toward that coverage, leaving the employee with $75 of the premium.

Perhaps the employee prefers a richer plan costing $850.

The employer’s allowance does not suddenly become 75% of $850. The employer has already established the allowance at $525. The employee can choose the more expensive plan and pay the additional cost.

That is the distinction I find most useful:

The employer first determines how the contribution will be calculated. The employee then makes an individual purchasing decision using the allowance that calculation produced.

Those are two separate decisions.

Bronze versus Silver may not mean what you think

This also explains why two ICHRA proposals can look so different.

One proposal might use a Bronze plan as the benchmark. Another might use Silver. A third might simply begin with an employer budget and establish dollar allowances from there.

That does not necessarily mean one employer is offering Bronze coverage while another is offering Silver coverage.

The plan may simply be the reference point used to establish the employer’s contribution.

Once the allowance is established, employees generally have the ability to purchase qualifying individual coverage available to them rather than being restricted to the particular plan used to calculate the allowance.

There is an important distinction for larger employers subject to the ACA employer shared responsibility rules. The lowest-cost Silver plan has a specific role in determining whether an ICHRA offer is considered affordable. The IRS generally measures the employee’s required contribution using the applicable lowest-cost self-only Silver plan for the employee’s location and age, reduced by the ICHRA amount.

That affordability benchmark should not be confused with whatever benchmark an employer or ICHRA provider may use when designing the employer’s contribution strategy.

The allowance is not simply cash

There is another point worth keeping straight.

An ICHRA allowance establishes how much the employer will reimburse under the arrangement. It is not simply additional compensation handed to the employee.

The employee must have qualifying individual health coverage, and the ICHRA reimburses eligible expenses according to the terms established by the employer. ICHRAs are employer-funded arrangements integrated with individual health insurance coverage or Medicare.

So when comparing ICHRA proposals, I would be careful with statements such as:

“The employer is paying 75% of the employee’s insurance.”

Maybe.

A more accurate description could be:

“The employer is using 75% of a particular benchmark premium to establish the employee’s ICHRA allowance.”

Those can produce very different results depending on the employee’s age, location and ultimate plan selection.

And then comes renewal

There is one more question I think employers should ask before adopting a benchmark approach:

What happens next year?

Suppose an employer establishes its contribution at 75% of a benchmark premium.

If that benchmark rises 12% at renewal, does the employer automatically continue paying 75% of the new amount?

Maybe that is exactly what the employer wants. It creates a consistent contribution formula and allows the employer contribution to adjust as individual-market premiums change.

But perhaps the employer has a specific benefits budget. In that case, automatically maintaining the same percentage could produce a larger increase than expected.

That is why the benchmark should not simply be something buried inside an ICHRA proposal.

It is part of the employer’s funding strategy.

The employer should understand what is being benchmarked, why that particular benchmark was selected, how the resulting allowances vary among employees and how the methodology will be handled at renewal.

The simple way to think about it

When an employer is presented with an ICHRA proposal based on a benchmark plan, I think there are really three questions to ask:

  1. What plan or premium are we using as the benchmark?
  2. What portion of that benchmark are we making available to employees?
  3. What dollar allowance does that produce for each employee?

Only after answering those questions do we get to the employee’s decision:

What health plan does this employee actually want to buy?

That separation between the employer’s funding decision and the employee’s purchasing decision is one of the most important concepts to understand about ICHRA.

And once you see it that way, a proposal based on Bronze and a proposal based on Silver become considerably easier to compare.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Talk With McCarthy Stevenot Agency

If your Ohio business is considering a CHOICE Arrangement, formerly known as an ICHRA, the employer contribution is only part of the decision.

Employers also need to consider the individual plans available to employees, provider networks, affordability rules, administration and how the arrangement compares with available group options.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency

to discuss whether a CHOICE Arrangement or traditional group health plan makes sense for your business, or call
513-891-9888.

Related Resources

Disclaimer

Broker’s Desk is a series of observations from more than three decades of helping Ohio small businesses and their owners navigate health insurance. Some articles explain a process. Others examine the tradeoffs behind real employer decisions. Client-identifying details may be omitted or generalized to protect privacy.

CHOICE Arrangement and ICHRA rules, individual-market premiums, plan availability, provider networks, contribution strategies and affordability calculations vary by employer, employee circumstances and location. Federal requirements may also change over time. This article is intended to explain practical considerations involved in evaluating an arrangement and is not legal or tax advice. Employers should review their specific circumstances with appropriate insurance, tax or legal professionals.

Is the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program Ending? What Ohio Employers Should Know for 2027

Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program 2027 changes featured in Broker’s Desk

Originally published September 16, 2026. Updated November 19, 2026.

The Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program is continuing. Medical Mutual of Ohio will replace UnitedHealthcare as the program’s administrator and stop-loss carrier on January 1, 2027. Employers who want to remain in the program need to select a new plan and complete the transition paperwork.

November update: We are now helping employers review their Medical Mutual proposals and prepare their submissions. Plan to submit your completed transition materials by December 15, 2026, and earlier whenever possible. Below, we explain what to gather, how to find your suggested replacement plan, and where to view benefit illustrations for all 15 plan options.

Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program transition to Medical Mutual for 2027

When an Ohio small business owner called me in September, her question was understandable: Is my health plan going away? Her company was enrolled in the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program, and she had received information indicating that something was changing.

At the time, there were still unanswered questions. We now have new plan designs, employer rate offerings, and instructions for completing the move to Medical Mutual.

What Is Changing with the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program?

The Ohio Chamber will continue sponsoring the self-funded multiple employer welfare arrangement, or MEWA. Medical Mutual will take over the administrative and stop-loss responsibilities currently performed by UnitedHealthcare.

The existing UnitedHealthcare-administered benefit plans expire December 31, 2026. Employers continuing in the program must choose their replacement coverage and complete the required application and enrollment steps for January 1.

That means reviewing new benefits, rates, provider access, and prescription coverage, as well as completing the paperwork.

What Do Ohio Chamber Employers Need to Submit?

As we help employers complete this transition, these are the items we are gathering for their Medical Mutual submissions:

  1. Completed employer master application. The employer completes and signs the new group application, even if the company is already participating in the Ohio Chamber program.
  2. Signed proposal or rate acceptance for the selected plan. Review the Medical Mutual options and sign the acceptance section for the plan your company chooses.
  3. Updated enrollment census and waiver information. Provide current information for employees enrolling in coverage and their covered dependents, along with the list of eligible employees waiving coverage. Use the current enrollment template supplied for your group.
  4. Ohio Chamber member number, if available. Include the company’s member number to help identify its membership. If you cannot locate your member number, contact us for help while you continue preparing the other materials.

The signed plan acceptance is one part of the submission. The employer application and updated enrollment information also need to be completed. Depending on the group’s circumstances, additional documents may be requested, including materials related to COBRA or continuation coverage.

Plan to submit your completed transition materials by December 15, 2026, following the instructions in your rate offering. Starting earlier allows more time to resolve questions and complete the setup.

Use the resource folder below to access the blank employer application, enrollment spreadsheet, and provider search instructions.

Open the Ohio Chamber Transition Forms and Provider Search Instructions

For enrollment updates, review the spreadsheet’s “Instructions-sold only” tab and complete the “census enrollment” and “waivers” tabs.

Download your own copies before entering information. The public folder is for blank resources only; completed applications and employee information should be returned securely.

Need Help Completing Your Ohio Chamber Transition?

If your company hasn’t received clear guidance—or you have a proposal in hand but aren’t sure what to do next—McCarthy Stevenot Agency can help.

We’re helping Ohio employers compare their Medical Mutual options, gather the required enrollment information, and work through the transition paperwork for January 1 coverage.

You don’t need to have the forms completed or a plan selected before contacting us. We can help you sort out the next steps and provide secure instructions for sharing your materials.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency or call 513-891-9888.

How Do You Find Your Suggested Medical Mutual Replacement Plan?

Your renewal packet includes a page titled Coverage Options with the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program. It appears on page four in the packets we are reviewing.

Find your current UnitedHealthcare plan ID in the right column, then look across to the suggested Medical Mutual plan in the left column. The table below reproduces those plan matches.

UnitedHealthcare-to-Medical Mutual Plan Matching Guide
Medical Mutual Plan Current UnitedHealthcare Plan ID
25-0-1000 EQ-ZX
2520-1000 EQ-ZD, EQ-ZL, EQ-ZT, EQ-ZU
25-0-2000 EQ-ZI, EQ-ZH
2520-2000 EQ-Y7, EQ-ZE, EQ-ZM, EQ-ZP, EQ-ZV
2520-3000 EQ-Y8, EQ-ZF, EQ-ZN, EQ-ZQ, EQ-ZW, EB-SJ
25-0-3500 EQ-ZJ, EQ-ZR, EQ-ZB
25-0-5000 EQ-Y9, EQ-ZK, EQ-ZC
2520-6000 EQ-ZA, EQ-ZG, EQ-ZO, EQ-ZS, EQ-ZY, EB-RW
HSA 3500/20% PD Rx* EQ-YM, EQ-YR, EQ-YX, EQ-Y2
HSA 5000/0% PD Rx* EQ-YN, EQ-YP, EQ-YQ, EQ-YS, EQ-YU, EQ-YY, EQ-Y3
HSA 7000/0% PD Rx* EQ-Y5, EQ-Y6, EQ-YO, EQ-YT, EQ-YV, EQ-YW, EQ-YZ, EQ-Y4
35-0-6500 Additional plan option
3520-7500 Additional plan option
HSA 3000/0% (aggregate) Additional plan option
HSA 8750/0% MMRx Additional plan option

* PD means post deductible. Source: Medical Mutual, Coverage Options with the Ohio Chamber Health Benefit Program (X12106-SMG 8.26).

If your current plan ID is not listed, the guide explains that Medical Mutual may not have received enough information to identify a recommended match. The available plan options remain open to you, and we can help identify the closest fit.

A suggested replacement is not necessarily an identical replacement, and you are not required to choose the suggested match. Compare the deductibles, coinsurance, out-of-pocket maximums, office visit benefits, prescriptions, and rates before deciding.

Once you choose a plan, sign the acceptance section for that plan’s rate offering. In the packets we are reviewing, the signature area appears below the quoted rates. Return the signed acceptance with the other required transition materials.

View the 2027 Medical Mutual Plan Benefit Illustrations

Medical Mutual offers 15 Ohio Chamber plan designs: 10 traditional copay plans and five Health Savings Account (HSA) compatible plans.

We have gathered the benefit illustrations for all 15 options in one folder. Use the Medical Mutual plan name from your proposal or the matching guide above to find the corresponding PDF.

View the 2027 Ohio Chamber Plan Benefit Illustrations

The folder opens in Google Drive and can be viewed without signing in. These documents outline benefits such as deductibles, office visits, hospital services, and prescription coverage. Your company’s rates are provided separately in its proposal.

These are illustrative benefit summaries, not the standardized Summary of Benefits and Coverage (SBC) documents or the complete plan contract. Refer to the applicable SBC and governing plan documents for additional details, limitations, and coverage terms.

What About Doctors, Hospitals and Prescription Drugs?

The new Ohio Chamber plans use Medical Mutual’s SuperMed provider network. Employees should check the physicians, specialists, hospitals, and facilities they expect to use.

For step-by-step help checking your doctors and hospitals, view the Medical Mutual provider search instructions (PDF). The guide explains how to search without logging in and select SuperMed PPO with Cigna PPO.

A provider’s participation in the current UnitedHealthcare network does not establish participation in the new network. Review the network for the specific plan and confirm with the provider when necessary.

Prescription drug benefits will be administered through Express Scripts. Employees who use maintenance medications, specialty drugs, mail-order prescriptions, or medications requiring prior authorization should review those arrangements before the transition.

Employees or dependents receiving ongoing treatment may qualify for transition-of-care accommodations. Examples can include cancer treatment, pregnancy-related care, or an upcoming medical procedure. Requests require Medical Mutual’s review and approval under the applicable requirements.

Raise provider, prescription, and ongoing-treatment questions early. That gives the employer, broker, providers, and Medical Mutual more time to address them before January 1.

Important Dates for Ohio Chamber Employers

  • December 1, 2026: Medical Mutual recommends accepting coverage and submitting completed implementation materials by this date to improve the likelihood of receiving identification cards before January 1.
  • December 15, 2026: Plan to have your completed employer transition package submitted by this date. Follow the submission requirements and any specific deadlines in your rate offering.
  • December 31, 2026: The existing UnitedHealthcare-administered benefit plans expire.
  • January 1, 2027: The new Medical Mutual-administered coverage takes effect for groups that complete the transition.

The Chamber’s public employer notice encourages completing enrollment by December 15. Medical Mutual also describes a December 1 through December 31 special open enrollment period for January 1 coverage, with January enrollment changes available for a February 1 effective date. Those employee enrollment windows should not be treated as an extension of the employer’s transition paperwork deadline.

Medical Mutual estimates approximately five to ten business days for implementation after receiving complete and accurate materials. Allow time for questions or corrections, and confirm that the submission has been received and any outstanding items have been resolved.

Employers should also confirm the length of their rate offer and their next renewal date, especially if their current plan does not have a January 1 anniversary.

Should Employers Compare Other Health Insurance Options?

The new Medical Mutual arrangement may work well for many participating employers. Choosing a replacement plan is also a reasonable time to compare the proposed benefits and rates with other available options.

Depending on the business, those alternatives might include another Ohio MEWA, a level-funded plan, an ACA-compliant small-group plan, or an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA).

An ICHRA allows an employer to establish a contribution toward employees’ qualifying individual health coverage. Other employers may find that a traditional group arrangement remains the better fit. The decision depends on costs, benefits, provider access, eligibility, and the needs of the employees.

For medically underwritten alternatives, completing or updating a health insurance prescreen can help establish which options are available and what they may cost. Completing a prescreen does not obligate an employer to change coverage.

We explain that process in our guide to health insurance prescreens for Ohio small businesses.

Keep the transition timetable in view while comparing alternatives. Establish a clear coverage plan for January 1, and obtain written confirmation of replacement coverage before canceling an existing arrangement.

Sources and Plan Resources

Editor’s note: This article was originally published September 16, 2026, updated October 15, 2026, and updated again November 19, 2026, to add practical submission guidance, the plan matching table, and access to the 2027 benefit illustrations. Follow the instructions in your group’s current rate offering and transition materials. Details remain subject to governing plan documents and subsequent program updates.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations, and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Related Resources

Where Does a 20% Health Insurance Renewal Increase Go?

20% health insurance renewal increase for an Ohio small business

I worked on another small-business health insurance renewal this week.

20% health insurance renewal increase for an Ohio small businessThis employer’s health insurance renewal increase was 20.6%.

Unfortunately, there is nothing particularly remarkable about writing that sentence anymore. We have been seeing difficult renewals repeatedly, and I suspect many Ohio employers heading into the January renewal season are going to have some uncomfortable decisions to make.

What interested me about this particular renewal wasn’t just the size of the increase.

It was what we had to do to the benefits to bring the increase down.

The employer’s current monthly health plan cost is about $2,583.

Keeping the existing benefit structure increases that to about $3,116 per month.

There are less expensive alternatives with the same carrier and general plan structure.

Moving from a $1,500 individual deductible to $2,000 reduces the renewal increase from 20.6% to 17.1%.

To get the increase below 10%, however, the individual deductible has to double to $3,000.

And even then, the employer is still paying 9.7% more than last year.

That is the part I think is worth examining.

What happens to a health insurance renewal increase as the deductible rises?

The numbers look like this:

What Happens to the Renewal Increase?
Current monthly plan cost: $2,583.17
Keep $1,500 deductible
$3,115.58/month   |   +20.6%
Move to $2,000 deductible
$3,024.28/month   |   +17.1%
Move to $3,000 deductible
$2,832.91/month   |   +9.7%
Bars represent the relative size of the renewal increase, not total premium.

The middle option is interesting.

Increasing the deductible from $1,500 to $2,000 saves the employer only about $91 per month compared with renewing the current plan.

That’s roughly $1,096 for the entire year.

The employer has taken on a meaningful benefit change, but the renewal is still 17.1%.

To make a larger dent in the premium, we have to make a larger change to the plan.

What does it take to get below 10%?

The $3,000 deductible alternative reduces the monthly cost by about $283 compared with renewing the existing benefits.

That’s approximately $3,392 in annual savings.

But look at the other side of the equation.

The individual deductible doubles from $1,500 to $3,000.

The family deductible doubles from $3,000 to $6,000.

The individual out-of-pocket maximum increases from $7,000 to $8,000, and the family maximum increases from $14,000 to $16,000.

What Changes to Get the Renewal Below 10%?

Individual Deductible

Current: $1,500
Alternative: $3,000

Family Deductible

Current: $3,000
Alternative: $6,000

Individual Out-of-Pocket Maximum

Current: $7,000
Alternative: $8,000

Family Out-of-Pocket Maximum

Current: $14,000
Alternative: $16,000

Not every benefit deteriorates.

The coinsurance remains 80%. The office visit copays remain the same. The urgent care copay remains the same. The prescription copays remain the same.

So an employee who primarily uses office visits and prescriptions might experience relatively little difference.

An employee who has significant medical claims could experience considerably more cost before reaching the plan’s out-of-pocket maximum.

That’s why I don’t think it is quite accurate to describe this as simply “finding a cheaper plan.”

The cost pressure didn’t disappear

This is what keeps getting my attention as I work through these renewals.

We can move things around.

We can change carriers.

We can change networks.

We can change deductibles.

We can change out-of-pocket maximums.

We can change the employer contribution.

Sometimes we can change the funding arrangement entirely.

But none of those things necessarily makes the underlying cost of healthcare disappear.

Sometimes we are simply deciding where the pressure is going to land.

In this case, keeping the existing benefits puts more of the pressure into the employer’s monthly plan cost.

Moving to the $3,000 deductible reduces some of that premium pressure, but transfers more potential cost to the people who actually use medical services.

The employer isn’t choosing between a 20.6% increase and no increase.

The choices illustrated here are a 20.6% increase with the existing benefits, a 17.1% increase with a somewhat higher deductible, or a 9.7% increase with a deductible that has doubled.

That is a very different way to look at the renewal.

Are employees going to absorb more of the next round of increases?

I don’t know yet.

One renewal certainly doesn’t establish a trend.

But there is enough evidence nationally that I think this is something worth watching.

KFF’s 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey found that average family premiums increased 26% between 2020 and 2025. Over that same five-year period, the average single deductible among workers who had a deductible increased 17%.

Claims data analyzed by the Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker show a similar recent divergence from a different direction. Between 2019 and 2023, spending by health plans for people with employer coverage increased 27%, while actual out-of-pocket spending increased 10%.

That does not mean employees have had an easy time with healthcare costs. They haven’t.

KFF found that in 2025, 53% of covered workers at employers with 10 to 199 workers were already enrolled in plans with single deductibles of at least $2,000, and 36% had deductibles of $3,000 or more.

But it does suggest that, recently, some measures of employee cost sharing have been increasing more slowly than the underlying plan cost.

That makes me wonder where the next round of pressure goes.

And there are signs that employers nationally are asking the same question. Mercer reported that employers have increasingly been making plan design changes that shift more cost to employees as health benefit costs accelerate. Its June 2026 research found that 48% of large employers expect to make medical plan changes for 2027, such as increasing deductibles or copays, that will result in higher employee out-of-pocket costs.

Large national employers are obviously not the same thing as an Ohio business with a handful of employees.

But the economic problem is recognizable.

Something has to give.

I think we’ll know more after the January renewals

I’ve written before about the different knobs available when a small employer receives a difficult health insurance renewal.

This case makes me think about the subject a little differently.

Maybe the important question over the next year isn’t simply:

How much are health insurance premiums increasing?

Maybe another question is:

Where are those increases ultimately landing?

Are employers absorbing them?

Are employees paying larger payroll contributions?

Are deductibles going higher?

Are out-of-pocket maximums increasing?

Are employers moving toward narrower networks or different funding arrangements?

Or are we going to see some combination of all of them?

I don’t think we have enough information yet to know exactly how this period will play out for Ohio small employers.

We probably won’t recognize the trend clearly until after it has already happened.

But I know what happened with this renewal.

The employer started with a 20.6% increase.

We could get that increase below 10%.

To do it, the individual deductible had to double.

The cost pressure didn’t disappear.

It moved.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Talk With McCarthy Stevenot Agency

If your Ohio small business is facing a health insurance renewal increase, we can help you review the available options and understand the tradeoffs.

Sometimes the best answer is to keep the existing plan. Other times it may make sense to change the benefit design, network, carrier, funding arrangement or overall approach. The objective is to understand what each alternative saves, what it changes and whether the disruption is worth it.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency to discuss your renewal, or call 513-891-9888.

Related Resources

Disclaimer

Broker’s Desk is a series of observations from more than three decades of helping Ohio small businesses and their owners navigate health insurance. Some articles explain a process. Others tell the stories behind the work. Client-identifying details may be omitted or generalized to protect privacy. Plan availability, eligibility, underwriting, benefits and rates vary by employer and program. These articles are intended to help readers understand how experienced brokers think through real-world situations, not to suggest there is one right answer for every business or individual.

ICHRA Is Now CHOICE: What Ohio Small Employers Should Know

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about CHOICE, formerly ICHRA, for Ohio small employers

The federal government has given ICHRA a new name.

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about CHOICE, formerly ICHRA, for Ohio small employers

On September 3, 2026, the U.S. Small Business Administration and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services announced that Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangements, better known as ICHRAs, will now be promoted as CHOICE Arrangements.

At first glance, this may look like little more than a branding exercise. In one sense, it is. The underlying benefit arrangement did not suddenly become something new.

But I think the announcement is more important than the name itself.

The federal government is no longer merely permitting employers to use ICHRA. It is now actively presenting the arrangement to small businesses as an alternative to traditional group health insurance. The SBA and CMS have also created new employer resources, including a cost estimator and information about third-party administrators.

That is a meaningful shift in visibility.

What Is a CHOICE Arrangement?

A CHOICE Arrangement is the benefit structure we have known as ICHRA since it became available in 2020.

Instead of selecting one group health plan for everyone, the employer establishes a defined amount of money to reimburse eligible employees for qualifying individual health insurance premiums and, depending on the plan design, certain other medical expenses.

The employee selects an individual policy based on considerations such as:

  • Premium
  • Deductible and out-of-pocket exposure
  • Prescription coverage
  • Physician and hospital networks
  • The needs of covered family members

When federal requirements are satisfied, employer reimbursements are generally tax-deductible to the business and tax-free to the employee.

Employers of any size can establish the arrangement as long as they have at least one eligible W-2 employee. That can make it relevant to very small employers that may not be able to establish a practical traditional group plan.

What Actually Changed?

The clearest change is the name.

ICHRA has never been an especially inviting acronym. It is difficult to say, easy to confuse with other HRAs and almost meaningless to an employer hearing it for the first time.

“CHOICE Arrangement” puts the employee-choice idea directly in the name.

Federal agencies are also giving the arrangement a more prominent small-business presentation. The SBA’s new CHOICE Arrangement page speaks to two specific audiences:

  1. Small employers that want to offer health benefits for the first time
  2. Employers considering leaving a traditional group health plan

The new CMS employer guide goes further. It explains contribution strategies, employee classes, eligible coverage, administration and the interaction between the employer contribution and the employee’s individual policy.

CMS has also published a directory of third-party administrators that can help employers establish and administer the arrangement.

The rules are not new. The public push is.

What Did Not Change?

A new name does not remove the tradeoffs.

Employees still need qualifying individual health insurance or Medicare, where permitted, to receive reimbursements. Employers still need a formal plan structure, required notices, substantiation and administration. Federal employee-class rules still matter. So do affordability rules and the interaction between an employer’s offer and an employee’s eligibility for a Marketplace premium tax credit.

The employee has more choice, but only among the individual plans available where the employee lives.

That distinction is especially important in Ohio. Carrier participation, provider networks, premiums and plan designs can vary materially from one county to another. An arrangement that works well for employees in Cincinnati may produce a different result for employees living in a rural county.

Nor does a CHOICE Arrangement make healthcare inflation disappear.

The employer controls its contribution more directly, which can make the employer’s budget more predictable. But if individual-market premiums increase and the employer does not increase its contribution, employees absorb more of the increase.

Predictable employer cost and affordable employee coverage are related, but they are not the same thing.

Does CHOICE Always Cost Less Than Group Health Insurance?

No.

The SBA announcement describes CHOICE Arrangements as a way for small employers to obtain health benefits at a fraction of the cost of traditional group insurance. That may be true in some cases, particularly for employers that are not offering coverage today or that face a very difficult group renewal.

I would not treat it as a universal promise.

The only responsible way to evaluate the difference is to compare the employer’s current or proposed group plan against the individual-market options available to the actual employees involved.

That comparison should include more than the employer’s total contribution. It should also consider:

  • What employees will pay after the employer reimbursement
  • Provider and prescription networks
  • Deductibles and maximum out-of-pocket exposure
  • Employee ages and home counties
  • The effect on Marketplace premium tax credits
  • The employee enrollment and service experience
  • Future contribution strategy

Sometimes the result will favor the CHOICE Arrangement. Sometimes a traditional group plan will remain the better fit.

Why the Federal Push Matters

ICHRA was created through federal rules issued during President Trump’s first administration and became available in 2020. The second Trump administration is now putting the SBA and CMS behind a coordinated effort to explain and expand its use.

To me, this is another sign that the model is becoming institutionally persistent.

The more employers use it, the more administrators build around it. The more administrators support it, the easier it becomes for brokers and employers to implement. Broader adoption may also give insurance carriers a stronger reason to compete for individual-market members and develop better products.

That does not guarantee ICHRA, or CHOICE, will become the dominant form of employer health insurance. It does mean the arrangement is moving farther from the edge of the market.

I recently described ICHRA as a bridge between the tax advantages of employer funding and the individual insurance market. The bridge now has a much larger federal road sign.

What Should an Ohio Small Employer Do?

The name change alone is not a reason to replace a group health plan.

It is a reason to understand the option.

For an employer considering benefits for the first time, a CHOICE Arrangement may create a workable path without requiring the company to choose one group plan for everyone.

For an employer facing another difficult group renewal, it may be worth comparing the renewal against the individual-market choices available to employees.

For now, employers will continue to see both terms. Federal agencies are using CHOICE Arrangements, while many carriers, administrators, brokers and existing documents still use ICHRA. They refer to the same underlying arrangement.

The name has changed. The real decision has not.

The question is still whether the arrangement works for the employer’s budget and for the employees who will depend on it.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Talk With McCarthy Stevenot Agency

If your Ohio business is considering an ICHRA, now called a CHOICE Arrangement, the employer contribution is only part of the decision.

Employers also need to consider the individual plans available to employees, provider networks, affordability rules, administration and how the arrangement compares with available group options.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency to discuss whether a CHOICE Arrangement or traditional group health plan makes sense for your business, or call 513-891-9888.

Disclaimer

Broker’s Desk is a series of observations from more than three decades of helping Ohio small businesses and their owners navigate health insurance. Some articles explain a process. Others examine the tradeoffs behind real employer decisions. Client-identifying details may be omitted or generalized to protect privacy.

CHOICE Arrangement and ICHRA rules, individual-market premiums, plan availability, provider networks, contribution strategies and affordability calculations vary by employer, employee circumstances and location. Federal requirements may also change over time. This article is intended to explain practical considerations involved in evaluating an arrangement and is not legal or tax advice. Employers should review their specific circumstances with appropriate insurance, tax or legal professionals.

Will ICHRA Become the 401(k) of Health Insurance?

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic asking whether ICHRA could become the 401(k) of health insurance

ICHRA is usually described as a different way for employers to pay for health insurance. Look more closely, and it begins to reveal a different structure for employer-sponsored healthcare.

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic asking whether ICHRA could become the 401(k) of health insuranceAn employer has a difficult year. Its health insurance renewal arrives 30 percent higher. Management changes carriers or provider networks to make the numbers work. An employee then discovers that the pediatrician her children have known for years is no longer in the network.

What does the employer’s difficult year have to do with her children’s relationship with their pediatrician?

Under traditional group health insurance, far more than it probably should.

That example is not theoretical to me. In 35 years of helping Ohio’s smallest employers, I have delivered brutal increases, watched owners struggle with decisions they never wanted to make and seen employees absorb the consequences when deductibles, carriers and provider networks changed. Some changes were unavoidable. Others were not. Either way, the employer’s business circumstances reached deeply into the employee’s personal healthcare relationships.

When I first began working with Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangements, or ICHRAs, I viewed them mainly as another way to fund health insurance. The basic mechanics are simple:

  • The employer determines how much it will contribute.
  • Employees use that money to reimburse premiums for qualifying individual health insurance they select for themselves.
  • The employer no longer chooses one group insurance policy and asks the entire workforce to fit inside it.

That is the mechanism. But it is not the whole story.

Follow the implications far enough and ICHRA begins to look less like a new employee benefit and more like a new piece of healthcare infrastructure. It changes who chooses the policy, where the insurance relationship lives, how the employer defines its commitment and where the covered population is pooled.

That leads to a much larger question:

Could ICHRA eventually do to traditional group health insurance what the 401(k) did to defined-benefit pensions?

The comparison is not exact. It does not need to be. The more useful question is whether ICHRA aligns incentives strongly enough to move employers from selecting and maintaining one health plan toward funding many individual choices.

The real comparison is not simply defined contribution to defined contribution.

It is incentive to incentive.

At a Glance

This article develops six principal ideas:

  1. The 401(k) comparison is fundamentally an incentive story. The 401(k) gave employers a way to exchange an open-ended pension obligation for a defined contribution. ICHRA gives employers a way to exchange the volatile annual burden of maintaining a group plan for a defined contribution toward coverage employees choose for themselves.
  2. ICHRA connects two systems that had largely operated apart. It creates a bridge from employer funding to the individual-market infrastructure established by the Affordable Care Act.
  3. Health insurance becomes a more individual decision. Employees select coverage around their own families, doctors and prescriptions instead of having those choices determined by the employer’s annual plan decision.
  4. ICHRA can help employers offer health benefits for the first time. A company that has considered health insurance out of reach can begin with a contribution it believes it can sustain.
  5. Once adopted, ICHRA may develop considerable staying power. Employee choices, administrative systems and successive new hires can turn the original decision into an enduring operating structure.
  6. Persistence could strengthen the individual market itself. More employed people and recurring employer contributions could create a deeper, better-balanced risk pool, improve carrier economics and encourage better products.

None of those outcomes is guaranteed. Pricing, carrier participation and networks remain local. Contributions can fall behind premiums, choice can overwhelm employees and regulation can change. ICHRA does not eliminate healthcare inflation or make every policy good. Even so, its incentives and early adoption merit examination.

Contents

  1. Why ask this question now?
  2. The 401(k) lesson: incentives can reshape a benefit system
  3. The bridge between employer funding and the individual market
  4. Health insurance is too personal for one employer decision
  5. The larger opportunity may be employers offering benefits for the first time
  6. Why ICHRA may become institutionally persistent
  7. How persistence could change the risk pool and the product
  8. Where the thesis can fail
  9. The HSA experience offers a useful lesson
  10. A promising structure, not a finished verdict

Why ask this question now?

ICHRA became available in 2020, just as the pandemic disrupted workplaces, employment and nearly every ordinary business decision. Its entrance was quieter than many advocates expected.

The more recent direction looks different.

  • 2022 to 2023: The number of American workers offered ICHRA coverage nearly tripled.
  • 2024: Overall HRA adoption increased nearly 30 percent, while ICHRA adoption among larger employers increased 83 percent.
  • 2025 to 2026: The HRA Council reported that ICHRA-covered lives roughly doubled and exceeded 500,000. More than 20,000 businesses offered either an ICHRA or a Qualified Small Employer HRA, up from approximately 13,000.
  • Large employers: Adoption among employers with 1,000 or more employees increased 178 percent in the Council’s aggregated data.

The latest figures come from the HRA Council’s 2026 data report. The Council is an industry organization, not a federal statistical agency. Its voluntarily submitted data comes from 17 administration platforms and more than 200,000 enrollment records, which it estimates capture 75 to 80 percent of ICHRA activity.

Those limitations caution against false precision, but the direction remains clear. Adoption has continued across successive reports and is spreading beyond the smallest employers.

The evidence does not prove that ICHRA will become the dominant structure for employer health benefits. It shows that the market has moved beyond a theoretical experiment.

We are no longer asking only whether ICHRA can work. The emerging question is what happens if adoption persists long enough to change the market around it.

Where this leaves us: We are early enough that the final outcome remains uncertain, but far enough along that dismissing ICHRA as a niche arrangement is becoming difficult.

1. The 401(k) lesson: incentives can reshape a benefit system

For much of the twentieth century, a traditional pension asked the employer to make a long-term promise. The employer sponsored the plan, managed its assets and assumed the responsibility and financial liability embedded in the retirement benefit. That promise could become especially painful when falling sales, inflation or industry decline arrived while pension obligations continued to grow.

The 401(k) changed that relationship. Under a defined-contribution arrangement, the employer and employee could contribute to an individual account, but the employer no longer promised a particular retirement income. The Department of Labor describes the distinction plainly: under a traditional defined-benefit pension, the employer bears the investment risk; under a 401(k), the employee’s eventual benefit depends on contributions and investment results.

The risk did not disappear. It moved.

The history is more accidental than many people realize. Congress added Section 401(k) through the Revenue Act of 1978 to address a narrow dispute over deferred compensation. The IRS formally described the rules in 1981. Benefits consultant Ted Benna is widely associated with recognizing how pretax contributions and employer matching could turn the obscure provision into a practical workplace savings plan.

The system did not immediately replace pensions. Early 401(k)s were often supplemental. Over time, however, the incentives began pushing in the same direction.

  • Employers could exchange an unpredictable long-term obligation for a defined contribution.
  • Employees received an individual account, tax advantages, portability and the possibility of employer matching.
  • The financial industry received a recurring flow of retirement assets and a reason to build products, administration and education around them.

The 401(k) did not become dominant merely because it was a clever product. It became dominant because several powerful participants had reasons to move it forward. Each new participant then made the system more familiar and useful to the next.

Traditional group health insurance creates a different legal obligation, so the comparison should not be pushed too far. A fully insured employer does not directly assume every medical claim; the insurer does. But the employer still bears the annual economic and organizational burden. It receives the renewal, chooses the carrier and network, determines its contribution and delivers the changes to employees. In experience-sensitive arrangements, the health and claims of its population can influence the outcome more directly.

The timing can be brutal. A 30, 40 or 50 percent renewal arrives whether the company is thriving or struggling to make payroll. Management must absorb the increase, transfer more to employees, reduce benefits, change carriers or stop offering coverage.

ICHRA does not make health insurance inflation disappear. Individual premiums still change. But the employer can define its contribution separately from the selection of one policy for the entire workforce. As I explained in a separate analysis of ICHRA renewal volatility, the employer gains more control over its response while remaining exposed to the broader individual market.

If one structure leaves employers carrying a volatile responsibility they never particularly wanted, while another allows them to define their commitment and still provide a meaningful benefit, employers have a reason to move.

Where this leaves us: The 401(k) comparison is not important because retirement accounts and health insurance are identical. It is important because both structures give employers a powerful incentive to replace a difficult promise with a defined contribution. Whether ICHRA grows will depend less on the elegance of the analogy than on the strength of that incentive.

2. ICHRA built a bridge between two systems

An employee using ICHRA may purchase the same ACA-compliant individual policy that was already available through the Marketplace or directly from an insurance company. The deductible, prescription coverage and provider network do not become better merely because an employer reimburses the premium.

The innovation is in the architecture surrounding the policy.

The Affordable Care Act had already created much of the necessary individual-market infrastructure: guaranteed access regardless of health, community rating, coverage standards, premium assistance and organized marketplaces. Whatever one thinks about the ACA as a whole, those rules made the individual market a more plausible home for employer-funded coverage.

But a critical connection was missing. The tax advantages and financial support associated with employer health benefits remained largely attached to employer-selected group coverage.

In 2019, the Treasury Department, IRS, Department of Labor and Department of Health and Human Services issued the final HRA rules allowing employer-funded HRAs to be integrated with qualifying individual coverage beginning in 2020.

The ACA created the individual-market infrastructure. ICHRA built the bridge to employer funding.

I find that insight difficult to overstate. The insurance policy may not be new. The pathway carrying tax-advantaged employer money to it is.

ICHRA may not be the final form of individually controlled health benefits. Its immediate importance is that it separates two functions employers have historically combined: funding coverage and choosing it.

The architects of the rule understood more of the problem than I initially assumed. They pointed to a continuing decline in small firms offering health coverage and noted that 80 percent of employers offering coverage provided only one option. The rule was intended to expand coverage, increase choice, encourage competition and mitigate adverse selection.

The individual mandate attempted to broaden the risk pool by requiring most people to obtain coverage or pay a penalty. The federal payment was reduced to zero beginning in 2019, but the economic problem remained. Guaranteed-issue coverage works best when healthy premium payers join people who need substantial care. The Congressional Budget Office has explained that employment-based coverage historically reduced adverse selection because workforces contain mixed health risks and employer contributions encourage enrollment.

ICHRA creates the possibility of directing those same employer contributions and mixed employee populations into the individual market without recreating a mandate. Instead of compelling individuals to buy coverage, the system gives employers a tax-advantaged way to help them buy it.

This is not limited to small employers. An Applicable Large Employer may use a properly structured offer in connection with its employer shared responsibility obligations. That design decision is essential. If ICHRA had been confined to tiny businesses, it might always have remained a useful niche. Access by large employers gives it a possible path to scale.

Where this leaves us: ICHRA may eventually accomplish through aligned incentives part of what the individual mandate attempted through compulsion: bring more employed, premium-paying people into the individual market. The bridge exists. We still need to see how much traffic it can carry.

3. Health insurance is too personal for one employer decision

When Jan and I selected a pediatrician for our children, we interviewed several doctors before choosing one. Our children came to know and trust Dr. Brown. She spoke directly with them and created the kind of relationship that made it easier for a child to be honest about how he or she felt.

Now imagine that relationship ending because an employer received a difficult renewal or simply decided to change plans.

I have watched versions of that throughout my career. An employer changes carriers or networks. Employees then have to reconsider doctors, prescriptions and planned procedures.

The employer may have a legitimate reason. A bad renewal can make the plan impossible to maintain. I also remember an employer abandoning a level-funded arrangement after a favorable result because management had never become comfortable with the structure. The plan was working, but the employer chose another direction. In either case, the people receiving care live with the consequences.

Why should the financial condition or momentary preference of an employer have so much power over an employee’s relationship with a pediatrician?

Employer-sponsored group insurance joins two things that are not naturally related: the business circumstances of the employer and the continuity of an employee’s personal healthcare relationships.

ICHRA begins to separate them.

The deeper structural shift is that the individual, rather than the employer group, begins to become the organizing unit of coverage and choice. The risk remains pooled across the individual market, but the coverage decision moves closer to the person receiving care.

The employer still decides how much to contribute and may change or end that contribution subject to applicable rules. But the employee selects the policy. A difficult business year does not automatically require everyone to abandon the same carrier and network.

An employee-selected individual policy also creates the possibility of greater portability. Employer funding generally ends with employment, but the policy may survive through personal funds, a Marketplace premium tax credit or a contribution from another employer. As people change jobs more frequently, coverage capable of surviving some employment transitions is better aligned with the way many people now work.

That is not guaranteed continuity. Individual plans renew annually. Carriers change networks or leave markets, and moving may require a new policy. Employees can select only from plans available where they live.

ICHRA therefore does not solve every form of healthcare disruption. It potentially removes one important source of it: the employer’s decision to replace everyone’s insurance at once.

Where this leaves us: Health insurance involves doctors, prescriptions, children and deeply personal decisions. ICHRA moves the choice closer to the person receiving care. Its success will depend on whether the individual market offers choices worth owning.

4. The larger opportunity may be employers offering benefits for the first time

Many ICHRA discussions begin with an employer trying to escape an expensive group renewal. That is the obvious application. The larger market may be employers that have no group plan to replace.

According to the HRA Council’s 2026 report, more than two-thirds of small businesses offering ICHRA had not previously offered health benefits. Nearly one-third moved to ICHRA from the traditional small-group market.

ICHRA is therefore functioning both as an exit from one system and as an entrance into employer-supported healthcare for the first time.

I think of this as the first-time benefits market.

That finding fits what I have watched in the small-employer market. After the ACA took effect, many small companies decided that group health insurance was simply too much to absorb. Costs increased, plan choices narrowed and participation became difficult. For years, insurance prospecting often began by asking for a company’s renewal date. The answer quickly revealed whether the employer offered health insurance at all.

ICHRA makes the absence of a renewal date newly interesting.

Instead of asking, “Can this company afford to establish a traditional group health plan?” an employer can ask, “How much can we sustainably contribute toward our employees’ individual coverage?”

That is a lower and more adjustable starting point. It may allow a company that has considered health insurance out of reach to begin offering something meaningful. It may also help the employer recruit a person who would never consider a job without health benefits.

An ICHRA can also accommodate employees with very different economic and household circumstances. One may use the allowance toward a full-price individual policy, while another chooses a richer plan and contributes more personally. An employee eligible for Medicaid or CHIP may decline the ICHRA and use that coverage. When the ICHRA is considered unaffordable, an otherwise eligible employee may be able to decline it and seek a Marketplace premium tax credit. These interactions require careful explanation and are addressed more fully in ICHRA, Marketplace Subsidies and Medicaid.

The democratizing quality is not that every employee receives the same outcome. It is that the employer can begin helping without first finding one insurance answer that works equally well for everyone.

The adoption data does not prove that every worker was previously uninsured. Some may have had coverage through a spouse, Medicaid or the individual market. The report shows expanded employer support, not an equal increase in insured people.

Where this leaves us: ICHRA may grow as much by opening a door for employers that have never offered health benefits as by replacing existing group plans. That is not merely a different way to distribute current spending. It is a possible new source of private funding for individual coverage.

5. Why ICHRA may become institutionally persistent

What happens after an employer adopts ICHRA?

The organization begins operating differently. Management establishes a contribution strategy, employees choose individual coverage, and an administrator handles eligibility and reimbursements. Enrollment and education develop around individual decisions. New employees enter the same system.

After a few years, returning to group coverage would require more than changing carriers. Employees could be asked to abandon policies and provider relationships they selected for themselves. The employer would again choose the carrier, network and plan structure for everyone.

That does not create contractual lock-in. An employer can decide that ICHRA no longer works. Poor individual-market renewals, weak networks, employee frustration or administrative problems could send the company back to group coverage.

But it does create institutional persistence.

Early retention data points in that direction. The 2026 HRA Council report indicates that 89.5 percent of small employers and 77.4 percent of Applicable Large Employers offering ICHRA were renewing from a prior year. These industry-reported figures from a young market are not proof of permanent behavior, but they suggest that many employers do not view ICHRA as a one-year emergency measure.

The longer the system remains in place, the more normal the defined-contribution model may feel to employers and employees. The original decision becomes an operating structure rather than an annual experiment.

That persistence can produce consequences beyond the company. Each employer that remains with ICHRA continues directing participating new employees into individual coverage. Successive hires keep directing lives and premium dollars into the same individual-market structure.

Where this leaves us: The important question may not be how many employers adopt ICHRA in one year. It may be how many adopt it and then see little reason to leave. Persistence is the mechanism that gives adoption a chance to compound.

6. Persistence could change the risk pool and the product

Insurance works by pooling unlike risks. Premiums from people with relatively low claims help pay for those who experience very high costs. No underwriting screen can permanently separate them because health changes. Illness, pregnancy and accidents arrive without notice.

A sustainable pool therefore needs more than enrollment. It needs enough premium, enough diversity of risk and enough continuity to absorb expensive outliers across time.

Employment-based insurance has historically helped limit adverse selection because employers assemble workforces for reasons unrelated to healthcare needs. Workforces include people across the health spectrum, and employer contributions encourage enrollment by people who might not purchase coverage solely because they expect to use it.

ICHRA can redirect that useful population dynamic into the individual market.

When an employer moves an eligible class to ICHRA, it cannot simply send employees with known claims into individual coverage. Federal safeguards include permitted employee classes, minimum class sizes in certain situations, same-terms rules and restrictions on offering employees within the same class a choice between group coverage and ICHRA.

The early demographics are encouraging. In the HRA Council’s 2026 data, 56 percent of Marketplace enrollments through ICHRA involved primary subscribers under age 45, and their dependents tended to be younger as well.

Younger does not automatically mean healthier. Credible claims and morbidity data across several years will be needed before anyone can say ICHRA has improved the market’s actuarial health. But the demographic direction is consistent with what the thesis would require.

If ICHRA adoption persists, the possible sequence looks like this:

  1. More employers direct participating employees and employer contributions into individual coverage.
  2. Those recurring inflows deepen the premium base and introduce people across a wider range of health risks.
  3. A larger, better-balanced pool becomes more capable of absorbing high-cost claims.
  4. More sustainable carrier economics give insurers a reason to remain in the market or enter it.
  5. Greater carrier participation can improve plan choice, provider networks, benefits and service.
  6. A better individual market makes ICHRA more attractive to the next employer.

That is the possible flywheel. Adoption improves the conditions for further adoption.

The consequences could extend beyond people receiving an ICHRA. Their policies participate in the same broader market as those purchased by self-employed people, early retirees and others without employer assistance. If employer-supported enrollment strengthens the pool, the effects can reach people with no relationship to the adopting companies.

A healthier individual market could lift boats far beyond the employers that helped strengthen it.

Medicare Advantage offers a loose illustration of how insurers behave when they see a large, durable market. Carriers compete through plan designs, networks and additional benefits. Its economics are different, so the comparison should not be pushed too far. The relevant lesson is that carrier investment follows dependable demand.

More carriers would not automatically lower the underlying cost of healthcare. Hospital prices, prescription costs, regulation and provider concentration would remain. Competition can still produce more choices, stronger service and pressure to improve value.

Where this leaves us: ICHRA’s largest possible contribution is not merely helping one employer escape one renewal. It is channeling employer money and mixed employee populations into the individual market persistently enough to improve the market itself. That outcome remains a hypothesis, but the mechanism is consistent with fundamental insurance principles.

Where the thesis can fail

A promising structure is not the same thing as a successful result.

The flywheel can stop at the county line

There is no single national individual insurance market. There is not even one uniform Ohio market. Availability, pricing and provider networks vary by county and rating area.

An employer may love the ICHRA concept and still discover that employees in one county have only one workable plan, while another employer has several carriers and credible networks. Statewide statistics can hide that local reality.

ICHRA can increase demand, but carriers must respond by maintaining or expanding useful products where employees live. If the local market is thin, individual choice becomes more theoretical than real.

Defined contribution does not eliminate healthcare inflation

An employer can control the ICHRA allowance. It cannot control individual-market premiums. If premiums rise and the contribution remains unchanged, employees absorb more of the increase. If the employer wants to preserve the same level of support, its contribution may need to rise.

Applicable Large Employers also need to consider affordability if they intend the ICHRA offer to satisfy employer shared responsibility requirements. A defined contribution gives the employer a decision. It does not isolate the company from the healthcare market.

Choice can become confusion

Employees may appreciate selecting their own plans, but individual coverage requires education and enrollment support. Provider networks, formularies, deductibles and household costs can differ substantially. Turning employees loose with a reimbursement amount and a link is not a benefits strategy.

Regulatory durability is essential

The 401(k) became foundational partly because employers, administrators and financial companies could build around rules that endured. ICHRA has operated under final federal regulations since 2020 and is incorporated into current IRS guidance. As with any tax-advantaged benefit, its long-term growth will depend partly on employers, carriers and administrators remaining confident that the framework will remain stable.

The practical test: Many employers may not need to adopt ICHRA today. But most employers should try to understand it. The concept must be tested against the actual workforce, actual contribution and actual individual plans available in every location involved. A practical ICHRA-versus-group comparison still has to be completed one employer at a time.

The HSA experience offers a useful lesson

I remember when Health Savings Accounts arrived. Employers wanted to know whether high-deductible plans would save money, whether the tax advantages justified the tradeoffs and whether consumer choice would reshape healthcare spending.

The results were less transformative than many expected. High-deductible plans often saved less premium than employers imagined, leaving limited room for a meaningful HSA contribution. The largest advantages tended to flow to people healthy enough not to spend the money and wealthy enough to leave it invested. Research continues to find large differences in HSA contributions and balances by income.

HSAs nevertheless proved valuable. They changed benefit conversations, created a durable market and gave people who understood them a useful financial tool. But they did not remake employer health insurance in the way some early advocates imagined.

ICHRA may follow a similar path. It could become an important structure without producing better results for every employer. The underlying policy may still have a narrow network, large deductible or difficult premium. Administration and employee education will still require work.

There is also an important difference. The HSA mostly changed how a person paid for cost sharing around an insurance plan. ICHRA can change who chooses the insurance policy, who funds it and where the insured population is pooled. Its potential structural reach is therefore larger.

The more useful test: ICHRA’s success should be measured by whether it improves the way employers fund coverage, employees select it and insurers pool the resulting risk, not by whether it solves every healthcare problem or produces immediate savings in every case.

A promising structure, not a finished verdict

I spent years criticizing much of the Affordable Care Act. I do not arrive at this conclusion as a natural cheerleader for government healthcare policy.

But good public policy can emerge when a consistent set of rules aligns human incentives toward a useful outcome. Looking at ICHRA, I have to acknowledge the possibility that the government got an important piece of this right.

The ACA established a market in which individuals could obtain coverage regardless of health. The ICHRA rules created a pathway for employer money to reach it. Employers can support healthcare without choosing one policy for everyone, employees can select coverage for their own households, and continued adoption can bring more premium and a broader population into the individual pool.

For the first time in decades of delivering difficult renewals, I can see a plausible path by which several persistent problems begin working in the other direction. Employers that previously offered no health benefit can begin contributing. Those exhausted by volatile renewals can establish a more deliberate commitment. Employees can move closer to owning the insurance decision, while their participation can deepen the individual pool and encourage the next employer to join.

That is not a prediction. It is a structure with the capacity to become self-reinforcing.

In 1981, when the IRS formally described the rules surrounding a narrow tax-code provision, it was not obvious that the 401(k) would alter the role of the traditional pension and redirect an enormous flow of retirement savings into individual accounts. The system developed one employer, one administrator and one employee at a time.

We may be standing near a similar moment in employer-sponsored healthcare.

Carrier participation must grow. Local markets must offer credible choices. Employer contributions must remain meaningful. Employees must receive enough help to make good decisions. The early demographic and adoption trends must eventually be confirmed by claims experience and long-term retention.

We will see.

What I can say now is that ICHRA is more than another way to reimburse an insurance premium. It separates decisions that were never naturally connected, aligns incentives that previously pointed in different directions and creates a bridge capable of carrying employer funding into the individual market.

ICHRA is not yet the 401(k) of health insurance. But the possibility is now substantial enough to take seriously.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Talk With McCarthy Stevenot Agency

An ICHRA can be compelling as a structure without being the best fit for every employer or workforce.

A meaningful comparison should consider employee locations, ages and coverage needs; actual individual-market premiums and provider networks; the employer’s proposed contribution; and the group health insurance alternatives available to the company.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency to discuss whether an ICHRA or traditional group health plan makes sense for your Ohio business, or call 513-891-9888.

Related Resources

Disclaimer

Broker’s Desk is a series of observations from more than three decades of helping Ohio small businesses and their owners navigate health insurance. Some articles explain a process. Others examine the tradeoffs behind real employer decisions. Client-identifying details may be omitted or generalized to protect privacy.

ICHRA contribution strategies, individual-market premiums, plan availability, provider networks and affordability calculations vary by employer, employee circumstances and location. Federal requirements may also change over time. Adoption figures cited in this article come from the identified third-party industry reports. Discussion of ICHRA’s possible long-term market effects represents analysis, not a prediction or a recommendation for any particular employer.

This article is provided for general informational purposes and is not legal, tax or actuarial advice. Employers should review their specific circumstances with appropriate insurance, tax or legal professionals.

ICHRA, Marketplace Subsidies and Medicaid: What Employers Need to Understand

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about ICHRA, Marketplace subsidies, and Medicaid for employers

One of the more complicated parts of evaluating an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement, or ICHRA, is understanding what happens to employees who may already qualify for Marketplace premium assistance or Medicaid.

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about ICHRA, Marketplace subsidies, and Medicaid for employers

This can matter a great deal for a small employer.

We recently worked with an Ohio employer considering an ICHRA whose workforce includes employees with very different health insurance situations. Some currently obtain coverage through Medicaid. Others may be able to purchase individual coverage with help from a Marketplace premium tax credit. Others may earn too much to qualify for either and would otherwise pay the full individual-market premium.

An ICHRA can work across a workforce like this, but the outcome is not necessarily the same for every employee.

The employer contribution is only one part of the equation.

An ICHRA Can Affect Marketplace Premium Tax Credits

The Premium Tax Credit, or PTC, is what people often mean when they refer to a Marketplace health insurance “subsidy.” It is a federal tax credit that can reduce the cost of qualifying health insurance purchased through the Health Insurance Marketplace.

Eligibility depends on several factors, including household income and whether the person has access to other qualifying affordable coverage.

Under current federal rules, an employee offered an ICHRA generally cannot receive both the ICHRA and a Marketplace premium tax credit for the same period.

The key question is whether the ICHRA is considered affordable.

If the ICHRA is affordable, the employee generally cannot decline it and receive a Marketplace premium tax credit instead.

If the ICHRA is unaffordable, the employee may decline, or opt out of, the ICHRA and potentially receive a Marketplace premium tax credit if the employee otherwise qualifies.

The IRS explains these rules in its Questions and Answers on the Premium Tax Credit.

That distinction can make the amount of the employer’s ICHRA contribution important for reasons beyond simply deciding how much the company wants to spend.

How Is ICHRA Affordability Determined?

The affordability calculation looks at the employee’s cost for the lowest-cost Silver plan for self-only coverage available in the applicable individual market, after subtracting the employer’s available ICHRA contribution.

Household income is also part of the employee-side affordability calculation.

For 2026, an ICHRA is considered affordable when the employee’s monthly cost for the applicable self-only lowest-cost Silver plan, after the ICHRA contribution, is less than 9.96% of one-twelfth of the employee’s annual household income. HealthCare.gov provides a practical explanation of ICHRA affordability.

For plan years beginning in 2027, the IRS has increased the required contribution percentage to 10.22%.

The percentage changes over time, so employers should use the current standard when evaluating an arrangement.

The important point is that ICHRA affordability is not determined simply by saying:

“The employer is paying 50% of the premium.”

Two employees can receive the same employer benefit structure and still have different circumstances because affordability and potential Marketplace assistance can depend on household income, employee age, location and the cost of the applicable individual-market benchmark.

The Same ICHRA Can Affect Employees Differently

Consider three employees working for the same company.

Employee One: No Marketplace Premium Tax Credit Available

One employee has household circumstances that do not produce eligibility for a Marketplace premium tax credit.

For that employee, the ICHRA may simply provide valuable employer-funded assistance toward the cost of individual health insurance.

Instead of paying the entire premium personally, the employee uses the employer’s ICHRA contribution toward qualifying coverage.

Employee Two: Potentially Eligible for a Marketplace Premium Tax Credit

Another employee has household circumstances that may otherwise qualify for a Marketplace premium tax credit.

Now ICHRA affordability matters.

If the employer’s ICHRA is affordable for that employee, the employee generally cannot opt out simply to obtain a premium tax credit.

If the ICHRA is unaffordable, the employee can choose to decline it and apply for Marketplace coverage with a premium tax credit, assuming the employee satisfies the other eligibility requirements.

The employee cannot use both the ICHRA and the Marketplace premium tax credit for the same period.

This creates an important decision point that employers should understand when establishing the ICHRA contribution.

What About Employees Who Qualify for Medicaid?

Medicaid operates differently.

ICHRA affordability does not determine whether someone qualifies for Medicaid or the Children’s Health Insurance Program, or CHIP.

HealthCare.gov specifically explains that when someone qualifies for Medicaid or CHIP, it does not matter whether the HRA is considered affordable. If the employee enrolls in Medicaid or CHIP instead, the employee declines or opts out of the ICHRA.

That means an employer could have an employee who remains eligible for Medicaid even though the employer is offering an ICHRA to the workforce.

This can be particularly important for employers with lower-wage employees or employees whose household circumstances vary significantly.

The employer does not need to become the Medicaid eligibility expert.

Medicaid is a joint federal-state program, but eligibility and enrollment are administered through each state’s Medicaid program. Employees who believe they may qualify should verify their circumstances with the Medicaid agency in their state.

Ohio employees can use the Ohio Benefits Self-Service Portal to check potential eligibility and apply for Medicaid and other benefits.

Think of This as Three Different Paths

It may be easier to think about an ICHRA workforce in three broad categories.

ICHRA + Individual Coverage

The employee accepts the ICHRA and uses the employer contribution toward qualifying individual health insurance.

Marketplace Coverage With a Premium Tax Credit

If the ICHRA is unaffordable and the employee otherwise qualifies for a premium tax credit, the employee may opt out of the ICHRA and choose Marketplace coverage with the tax credit instead.

Medicaid or CHIP

If the employee qualifies for Medicaid or CHIP and enrolls, the employee opts out of the ICHRA and uses that coverage instead.

One employer can potentially have employees in all three situations.

The Employer Does Not Determine an Employee’s Marketplace Premium Tax Credit

The employer establishes the ICHRA contribution and provides the required information about the arrangement.

But the employer generally does not know everything necessary to determine an employee’s actual Premium Tax Credit eligibility.

Household income is one obvious reason.

An employee’s salary from the company is not necessarily the same thing as household income. A spouse may work. There may be other household income. Household size and other eligibility factors can also matter.

The Marketplace evaluates the employee’s circumstances when the employee applies.

That is a much safer process than an employer or broker attempting to predict every employee’s final eligibility.

Applicable Large Employers Have Another Consideration

For an Applicable Large Employer, or ALE, there is another layer.

An ALE is generally an employer that averaged at least 50 full-time employees, including full-time-equivalent employees, during the preceding calendar year, subject to the applicable federal counting rules.

An ALE using an ICHRA as its health coverage offer needs to consider the Affordable Care Act’s employer shared responsibility requirements.

The employer still determines the ICHRA contribution, but affordability becomes part of evaluating whether the offer satisfies those requirements.

Because an employer generally does not know each employee’s household income, federal rules provide employer affordability safe harbors. Separate ICHRA rules also address how the applicable lowest-cost Silver premium is determined for employer shared responsibility purposes.

That employer compliance analysis is related to, but not necessarily identical to, the actual Premium Tax Credit determination for an individual employee.

For a smaller employer that is not subject to the employer shared responsibility provisions, those employer-mandate requirements do not apply. The employer may therefore have more flexibility from an employer-mandate standpoint when establishing its contribution.

But the contribution can still affect employees because it may determine whether an employee’s ICHRA is affordable and therefore whether Marketplace premium assistance remains available.

There Are Actually Two Different Silver Benchmarks

One detail can make this discussion particularly confusing.

The lowest-cost Silver plan is used in determining ICHRA affordability.

The amount of an employee’s actual Premium Tax Credit, when the employee qualifies for one, is generally calculated using the second-lowest-cost Silver plan applicable to the employee’s coverage family.

The IRS explains the second-lowest-cost Silver benchmark in its Premium Tax Credit Q&A.

Those are two different calculations.

The employee also does not have to enroll in either benchmark plan merely because that plan was used for a federal calculation.

That is another reason employers should be cautious about assuming that a reference to a “Silver plan” tells them what coverage employees will actually choose.

The Contribution Is More Than a Budget Number

One of the attractive features of an ICHRA is that an employer can establish a defined contribution toward health insurance.

But that contribution does more than establish the company’s cost.

For some employees, it may simply reduce the cost of individual coverage they would otherwise purchase without assistance.

For another employee, the contribution may affect whether the ICHRA is considered affordable and therefore whether a Marketplace premium tax credit remains an option.

Another employee may qualify for Medicaid under separate eligibility rules and decide not to use the ICHRA at all.

That does not make an ICHRA a bad fit.

In fact, a workforce with very different income levels, locations and existing coverage situations can sometimes be one of the situations where an ICHRA deserves serious consideration.

It does mean the employer should understand what it is offering.

With an ICHRA, the employer contribution does not just determine how much the employer spends. It can also affect which coverage pathways remain available to employees.

That is why evaluating an ICHRA should include more than choosing an allowance and looking at a spreadsheet of individual premiums.

The employer should also understand how affordability works, how employees will evaluate Marketplace assistance, what happens to employees who may qualify for Medicaid, and where employees should go to receive an actual eligibility determination.

That is part of deciding whether the ICHRA will work for the workforce, not just for the employer’s budget.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an employee use an ICHRA and receive a Marketplace premium tax credit at the same time?

Generally, no. An employee cannot use an ICHRA and receive a Marketplace Premium Tax Credit for the same period.

If the ICHRA is considered affordable, the employee generally cannot decline it and receive a premium tax credit instead. If the ICHRA is unaffordable, the employee may be able to opt out of the ICHRA and qualify for a premium tax credit if the other eligibility requirements are met.

What happens if an ICHRA is considered unaffordable?

An employee offered an unaffordable ICHRA may choose to opt out of the arrangement and apply for Marketplace coverage with a Premium Tax Credit if the employee otherwise qualifies.

The employee cannot receive the ICHRA reimbursement and the Premium Tax Credit for the same period.

Does offering an ICHRA make an employee ineligible for Medicaid?

No. ICHRA affordability does not determine Medicaid or CHIP eligibility.

An employee who qualifies for Medicaid or CHIP may enroll in that coverage and decline the ICHRA. Medicaid eligibility is determined under the rules applicable in the employee’s state, so employees who may qualify should verify their circumstances with their state Medicaid agency.

Can two employees with the same ICHRA allowance have different Marketplace subsidy outcomes?

Yes.

Employees receiving the same ICHRA allowance may have different affordability or Premium Tax Credit outcomes because household income, age, location, household size and the applicable individual-market premiums can differ.

The employer contribution may be the same, but the employee’s personal circumstances may not be.

Does the employer decide whether an employee qualifies for a Premium Tax Credit?

No.

The employer establishes the ICHRA and provides information about the contribution. The Marketplace determines whether an employee qualifies for a Premium Tax Credit based on the employee’s circumstances and the applicable federal rules.

This is important because the employer generally does not know everything that may affect an employee’s eligibility, including total household income.

Is the Silver plan used for ICHRA affordability the same Silver plan used to calculate the Marketplace Premium Tax Credit?

Not necessarily.

ICHRA affordability generally uses the applicable lowest-cost Silver plan for self-only coverage.

The amount of a Marketplace Premium Tax Credit, when an employee qualifies for one, is generally based on the applicable second-lowest-cost Silver plan.

Neither benchmark requires the employee to enroll in that particular Silver plan.

Do Applicable Large Employers have different ICHRA affordability considerations?

Yes.

An Applicable Large Employer, generally an employer with at least 50 full-time employees including full-time-equivalent employees under the applicable federal counting rules, must also consider the Affordable Care Act’s employer shared responsibility requirements.

An ALE still determines the ICHRA contribution, but affordability becomes part of evaluating whether the employer’s offer satisfies those requirements. Federal affordability safe harbors may be used because employers generally do not know each employee’s household income.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Talk With McCarthy Stevenot Agency

If your Ohio business is considering an ICHRA, the contribution amount is only part of the decision.

Employers also need to consider the individual plans available to employees, how the contribution will be established, what may happen when individual-market premiums change and how affordability rules may affect the arrangement.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency to discuss whether an ICHRA or traditional group plan makes sense for your business, or call 513-891-9888.

Related Resources

Disclaimer

Broker’s Desk is a series of observations from more than three decades of helping Ohio small businesses and their owners navigate health insurance. Some articles explain a process. Others examine the tradeoffs behind real employer decisions. Client-identifying details may be omitted or generalized to protect privacy.

ICHRA contribution strategies, individual-market premiums, plan availability and affordability calculations vary by employer, employee circumstances and location. Federal requirements may also change over time. This article is intended to explain practical considerations involved in evaluating an ICHRA and is not legal or tax advice. Employers should review their specific circumstances with appropriate insurance, tax or legal professionals.

ICHRA Renewal Volatility: What Employers Actually Control

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about ICHRA renewal volatility and what employers actually control

ICHRA renewal volatility works differently from renewal volatility under traditional group health insurance. One of the commonly cited advantages of an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement, or ICHRA, is greater control over health insurance costs.

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about ICHRA renewal volatility and what employers actually control

Instead of receiving a traditional group renewal from an insurance carrier, the employer establishes an amount it is willing to reimburse employees for individual health insurance.

That sounds straightforward. Set the contribution. Control the budget.

It is true, but there is more to it.

We recently received an ICHRA proposal for a small Ohio employer that helped illustrate what “cost control” actually means, particularly when it comes to future renewals.

The Contribution Has to Start Somewhere

The proposal showed two possible employer contribution strategies.

One would reimburse approximately 50% of the premium for the lowest-cost Silver plan available in the individual market. The other used 75%.

The actual contribution varied by employee age and geographic rating area.

That does not mean employees have to buy that particular Silver plan. Employees can choose from the individual plans and carriers available where they live.

The lowest-cost Silver plan was simply being used as a consistent benchmark for establishing the employer’s initial contribution.

That distinction becomes important when we start thinking about next year.

What Happens When Individual Rates Increase?

Suppose an employer initially establishes an ICHRA contribution equal to roughly 50% of the lowest-cost Silver plan.

Then individual-market premiums increase the following year.

What happens to the employer contribution?

The answer is: the employer decides.

It could increase its contribution enough to maintain approximately the same relationship to the Silver benchmark.

It could increase the contribution by a smaller amount based on its budget.

Or it could leave the contribution unchanged.

The original 50% calculation does not permanently obligate the employer to maintain that percentage.

That is an important form of cost control.

But notice what did not happen.

The health insurance increase did not disappear.

If individual premiums rise 15% and the employer leaves its contribution unchanged, employees absorb more of the increase.

If the employer increases its contribution enough to maintain the same relative support, the employer absorbs more of it.

Or the increase can effectively be shared.

ICHRA does not make health insurance inflation disappear. It gives the employer more control over how it responds to it.

But What About Renewal Volatility?

This is where I think ICHRA can offer a meaningful advantage, but we need to be precise about what kind of volatility we are talking about.

We recently reviewed a traditional employer health plan covering approximately 120 insured lives. Its renewal increase was approximately 59%.

A few years earlier, the same employer had received a renewal increase of roughly 4%.

That is a very wide range.

Traditional employer plans, particularly once we move beyond the ACA small-group market, can have a meaningful relationship to the claims experience and risk characteristics of the employer’s own population. A bad claims year, large ongoing claimants or other underwriting factors can have a substantial impact on the renewal.

An ICHRA moves employees into the individual insurance market.

ACA individual-market premiums cannot be based on an individual’s health status or claims history. Premiums can vary based on permitted factors including age, geography, family size and tobacco use.

That means one employer’s bad claims year does not result in that employer receiving its own 40%, 50% or 60% individual-market renewal.

That particular kind of employer-specific volatility is largely removed from the equation.

But market volatility remains.

Individual Rates Can Move Too

It would be a mistake to turn this into an argument that individual rates only increase by a few percentage points every year.

They don’t.

In Ohio, KFF data show that the average lowest-cost Silver premium increased about 5.1% from 2023 to 2024 and about 1.4% from 2024 to 2025. Then it increased approximately 17% from 2025 to 2026. Nationally, the average lowest-cost Silver premium increased approximately 26% from 2025 to 2026.

So I would not tell an employer that moving to an ICHRA eliminates renewal volatility or guarantees smaller future rate increases.

It doesn’t.

What changes is the source of the volatility.

With a traditional medically influenced employer renewal, the experience of that particular employer can play a significant role.

With an ICHRA, the employer is much more directly exposed to what is happening in the broader individual insurance market where its employees live.

Those are different risks.

The Employer Controls the Response

This is the part of ICHRA that I think is sometimes oversimplified.

With traditional group insurance, the carrier delivers the renewal.

The employer might receive a 12% increase, a 25% increase or, occasionally, something substantially worse. The employer then has to decide what to do with the renewal it has been given.

With an ICHRA, individual-market premiums change, but the employer gets to make a separate decision about its contribution.

Imagine an employee whose applicable Silver premium is $700 per month and whose employer initially provides $350.

The following year that premium increases 15% to $805.

The employer has choices.

It could increase the reimbursement to approximately $402.50 and maintain the same 50% relationship.

It could increase the reimbursement to $375.

Or it could leave it at $350.

The individual-market increase is the same in all three examples.

What changes is the employer’s response.

That is why I would describe the ICHRA advantage this way:

ICHRA can reduce employer-specific renewal volatility. It does not eliminate individual-market volatility. More importantly, it gives the employer more control over how much of a future increase it chooses to absorb.

Small Employers and Large Employers Are Not Quite the Same

There is another consideration.

A smaller employer that is not subject to the Affordable Care Act’s employer shared responsibility provisions has considerable flexibility to determine what it wants to contribute from year to year.

It could hold its ICHRA allowance flat.

But even then, the contribution does not exist in a vacuum. Whether an ICHRA is considered affordable can affect an employee’s eligibility for a Marketplace premium tax credit. An employee offered an affordable ICHRA generally cannot simply decline it and receive a premium tax credit instead. An employee offered an unaffordable ICHRA may be able to opt out and qualify for a premium tax credit if the other eligibility requirements are met.

For an Applicable Large Employer, or ALE, the issue becomes more important from the employer’s perspective as well.

An ALE using an ICHRA to satisfy its employer shared responsibility obligations needs to pay attention to affordability. The ICHRA affordability framework uses the applicable lowest-cost Silver plan for self-only coverage in determining the employee’s required contribution. The IRS also provides employer affordability safe harbors because employers generally do not know an employee’s household income.

So an ALE still controls its ICHRA contribution. But if it wants the ICHRA to remain affordable for employer shared responsibility purposes, it cannot necessarily treat that contribution as permanently disconnected from what is happening to individual-market premiums.

There is still a benchmark to watch.

Cost Control Is Not the Same as Cost Isolation

I still think cost control is one of the stronger arguments for considering an ICHRA.

But we should be careful about what we mean by it.

An employer can establish a defined contribution.

It can decide each year whether to increase that contribution.

It can potentially avoid the employer-specific claims volatility that sometimes produces very large traditional group renewals.

And it can establish a health-benefit budget with much more direct control over what the company itself will spend.

But the employer has not escaped the health insurance market.

Individual premiums can still increase. Employees can still face higher costs. Affordability rules still matter. And an employer that wants to maintain a particular level of employee support may find that its contribution needs to increase over time.

So perhaps the better way to think about an ICHRA is not that it eliminates renewal volatility.

It changes the nature of the volatility and gives the employer more control over the response.

For some employers, particularly those experiencing difficult or unpredictable traditional group renewals, that can be a meaningful advantage.

But it is not the same thing as setting a contribution once and forgetting about health insurance costs forever.

Client-identifying details have been omitted or generalized. The contribution examples discussed in this article are based on an actual ICHRA proposal and are included to illustrate how employers may think about contribution strategy, renewal volatility and affordability. Individual-market premiums, plan availability, contribution strategies and affordability calculations vary by employer, employee location and applicable federal requirements.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Talk With McCarthy Stevenot Agency

If your Ohio business is considering an ICHRA, the contribution amount is only part of the decision.

Employers also need to consider the individual plans available to employees, how the contribution will be established, what may happen when individual-market premiums change and how affordability rules may affect the arrangement.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency to discuss whether an ICHRA or traditional group plan makes sense for your business, or call 513-891-9888.

Related Resources

Disclaimer

Broker’s Desk is a series of observations from more than three decades of helping Ohio small businesses and their owners navigate health insurance. Some articles explain a process. Others examine the tradeoffs behind real employer decisions. Client-identifying details may be omitted or generalized to protect privacy.

ICHRA contribution strategies, individual-market premiums, plan availability and affordability calculations vary by employer, employee circumstances and location. Federal requirements may also change over time. This article is intended to explain practical considerations involved in evaluating an ICHRA and is not legal or tax advice. Employers should review their specific circumstances with appropriate insurance, tax or legal professionals.

What Does It Take to Make a 12% Health Insurance Renewal Increase Disappear?

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about reducing a 12% small-business health insurance renewal increase

A small employer I work with recently received a 12.1% increase on its health insurance renewal. It became a good example of how health insurance renewal tradeoffs actually work.

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about reducing a 12% small-business health insurance renewal increase

The group has three people enrolled, all with single coverage.

There were plenty of alternative plans available. But when I review a renewal, I don’t look at every cheaper plan as though it is equally attractive.

I’m also thinking about disruption.

Can we keep the same carrier?

Can we keep the same provider network?

Can we keep the same general type of plan?

Can we keep the way employees use the plan reasonably familiar?

And then, within those boundaries, how much can we do about the cost?

That is really what a lot of small-group renewal work comes down to.

Health insurance renewal tradeoffs: the knobs you can turn

Health insurance does not have one knob marked “cost.”

There are several:

  • Carrier
  • Provider network
  • Plan type
  • Deductible
  • Out-of-pocket maximum
  • Copays
  • Coinsurance
  • Prescription coverage
  • Employer contribution
  • Premium

Move one and something else may change.

A lower premium might require a higher deductible.

Another carrier might have a better rate but a different network.

An HSA-compatible plan might cost less but require employees to use their benefits differently.

A narrower network might create savings but affect someone’s doctor or hospital.

The job is not simply to find the lowest number on the spreadsheet.

Sometimes there are several reasonable choices. Sometimes, as I have written about before, there are no particularly good renewal options.

It is to decide which knobs are worth turning.

Start with the path of least resistance

Health insurance has a certain amount of inertia built into it.

People know their doctors. They know where they go for care. They are familiar with their insurance card, their copays and how their prescriptions work.

There is value in not disturbing all of that unnecessarily.

So in this case, I started by looking at what we could accomplish without changing carriers, without changing networks and without moving the employees into a fundamentally different type of health plan.

That left benefit design and premium as the primary variables.

The comparison looked like this:

Benefit Renew Current Plan Alternative Near-Flat Renewal
Individual Deductible $3,000 $5,000 $6,000
Family Deductible $6,000 $10,000 $12,000
Individual Out-of-Pocket Maximum $8,000 $7,150 $8,500
Primary/Specialist Copays $15 / $50 $15 / $50 $15 / $50
Prescription Tiers $10 / $50 / $125 / $300 $10 / $50 / $125 / $300 $10 / $50 / $125 / $300
Monthly Premium $2,104.56 $2,023.26 $1,892.61
Renewal Increase 12.1% 7.7% 0.8%

The group’s current premium is $1,877.91 per month.

If they keep the current plan, the new premium is $2,104.56.

If they move to the third option, the premium is $1,892.61.

That is only $14.70 more per month than they are paying today.

For the entire year, the increase is $176.40.

So what did it take to make the increase almost disappear?

In this particular renewal, we could get the increase down to less than 1% without changing the carrier.

We could keep the same network.

And we could stay with the same general type of plan.

The most visible tradeoff was the deductible, which moved from $3,000 to $6,000 for an individual.

Other benefits moved too, which is why plans should never be compared on deductible alone. For example, the middle option actually has a lower individual out-of-pocket maximum than the current plan.

But the comparison gives us something useful.

Within this carrier’s available plans, we can see approximately how much the benefit structure has to change to take a 12.1% renewal increase down to less than 1%.

Now the employer can decide what continuity is worth

There is another way to look at the numbers.

Keeping the current plan costs $2,104.56 per month.

The near-flat alternative costs $1,892.61.

The difference is $211.95 per month, or $2,543.40 for the year.

So instead of asking:

“Do we want to accept a 12.1% increase?”

I think the more useful question is:

“Is keeping the current benefit structure worth another $2,543 to the company this year?”

For some employers, it will be.

For others, the higher deductible will be a reasonable tradeoff to keep the premium almost unchanged.

Neither answer is automatically right.

The point is to make the tradeoff visible. That is a big part of having a consistent health insurance renewal process rather than simply reacting to the new rate when it arrives.

Small employers usually cannot make the underlying trend disappear

There are larger employers that can directly attack claims costs through plan design, utilization management, pharmacy strategy, steerage and other approaches.

That is a different conversation.

A small employer generally has much less ability to change the underlying forces that cause health insurance rates to increase during the coming year.

Most of the available choices have already been designed and priced by the carrier.

So when another renewal increase arrives, much of the job becomes deciding how that increase is going to land.

Do we absorb more of it in premium?

Do employees absorb more through deductibles or other cost sharing?

Do we change networks?

Do we change carriers?

Do we change the employer contribution?

These are the health insurance renewal tradeoffs small employers face every year.

Premium is only one of the variables. Every choice moves one of the knobs.

The objective is not disruption for the sake of finding a lower rate.

It is to contain the disruption while managing a cost increase that may not be avoidable.

In this case, we could keep most of the familiar pieces in place and see exactly what it would take to make a 12.1% increase almost disappear.

The employer may still decide to pay the 12.1%.

But now it is a decision rather than just a renewal.

Client-identifying details and plan names have been omitted or generalized. The premiums and benefits shown reflect a specific employer renewal and are included to illustrate the decision-making process. Plan availability, eligibility, underwriting, benefits and rates vary by employer and are subject to current carrier and program requirements.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Talk With McCarthy Stevenot Agency

If your Ohio small business is facing a health insurance renewal increase, we can help you review the available options and understand the tradeoffs.

Sometimes the best answer is to keep the existing plan. Other times it may make sense to change the benefit design, network, carrier, funding arrangement or overall approach. The objective is to understand what each alternative saves, what it changes and whether the disruption is worth it.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency to discuss your renewal, or call 513-891-9888.

Related Resources

Disclaimer

Broker’s Desk is a series of observations from more than three decades of helping Ohio small businesses and their owners navigate health insurance. Some articles explain a process. Others tell the stories behind the work. Client-identifying details may be omitted or generalized to protect privacy. Plan availability, eligibility, underwriting, benefits and rates vary by employer and program. These articles are intended to help readers understand how experienced brokers think through real-world situations, not to suggest there is one right answer for every business or individual.

Can a One-Employee Ohio Employer Get Group Health Insurance? A Real Case Study

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about whether a one-employee Ohio employer can get group health insurance

Can an Ohio employer with one employee get group health insurance? In some circumstances, yes.

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about whether a one-employee Ohio employer can get group health insurance

One employee group health insurance in Ohio isn’t available through every type of arrangement, but one of the smallest groups we work with recently received its first renewal.

They have one employee.

Before establishing this plan, the organization had never offered group health insurance. They had an employee they wanted to insure, though, and they were willing to go through the process necessary to make it happen.

That process wasn’t insignificant.

We first had to determine what options were realistically available. The employer went through a health insurance prescreen. The employee completed the information necessary for underwriting. We evaluated the available plans and benefits. The organization completed the required membership process.

Then we had to answer a question every employer faces when offering health insurance for the first time:

Which plan do you actually choose?

Starting From Scratch Is Harder Than Renewing a Plan

At renewal, you at least have something to compare.

You know what the current deductible is. You know what the premium costs. You know how the employee feels about the coverage.

A new group doesn’t have any of that.

There may be dozens of plan designs with different deductibles, coinsurance levels, copays and out-of-pocket maximums.

Eventually, this employer selected a PPO plan with a $2,500 individual deductible.

After the deductible, covered major medical expenses were paid at 100% in-network. The individual out-of-pocket maximum was $7,000. Primary care and specialist visits had $30 and $60 copays, along with separate prescription copays.

It was a solid benefit package.

Then they spent the next year covered under it.

Then the First Renewal Arrived

The renewal increase was 7.51%.

The employee’s monthly premium increased from approximately $595 to $639.

Nobody enjoys a 7.51% health insurance increase, but renewals don’t exist in isolation.

For context, Peterson-KFF’s August 2026 analysis of proposed 2027 ACA-compliant small-group rates found a median proposed increase of approximately 14% nationally. Insurers in those filings were estimating underlying medical cost trend at a median of 10.8%. Individual ACA Marketplace insurers are proposing a median increase of approximately 15% for 2027.

Those aren’t direct comparisons to this particular MEWA renewal, and this group’s renewal occurs before the 2027 plan year.

But they do help put a 7.51% increase into perspective.

This was a pretty good renewal.

A Good Renewal Still Deserves a Review

It would have been easy to stop there.

The renewal wasn’t alarming. The plan was working. There was only one employee.

Renew it and move on.

But that’s not really a renewal review.

When I went through the available alternatives, one plan in particular caught my attention.

One employee group health insurance Ohio renewal plan comparison
The renewal and one alternative we reviewed for this one-employee Ohio group. Identifying information has been removed.

Its monthly premium was approximately $590, almost $50 per month below the renewal premium and actually a few dollars below what the employer had been paying during the previous year.

There was a tradeoff.

The alternative plan had a lower $2,000 deductible, but after meeting the deductible the plan paid 80% rather than 100%. Its individual out-of-pocket maximum increased from $7,000 to $7,500.

The office visit and prescription copays remained essentially the same.

This is also a useful reminder that you can’t judge a health plan simply by looking at the deductible.

Although the deductible is lower, the 80% coinsurance and slightly higher out-of-pocket maximum create greater potential cost exposure for the employee.

In exchange for that greater potential out-of-pocket exposure, the premium drops by roughly $600 per year.

That’s a real option.

Whether it’s worth making the change is another question.

My suspicion is that this employer may simply renew the existing plan.

And that would be perfectly reasonable.

The purpose of reviewing a renewal isn’t to manufacture a change. Sometimes the review confirms that what you already have remains the best place to be.

What This One-Employee Group Actually Built

There’s another part of this case that I think is easy to miss.

This employer didn’t simply buy health insurance for one employee.

They established a functioning group health insurance arrangement.

The COSE Benefit Plan is a multiple employer welfare arrangement administered by Medical Mutual. At the time of publication, the COSE Benefit Plan is available to qualifying Ohio businesses with one to 50 employees.  Employers must meet applicable eligibility and underwriting requirements and participate through COSE or an affiliated chamber.

That meant more work at the beginning.

But now the structure exists.

If the organization eventually hires additional eligible employees, it isn’t starting the health insurance conversation from zero again. Subject to the plan’s rules and eligibility requirements, it already has an established group arrangement into which future employees may be enrolled.

That matters.

A business doesn’t suddenly have to figure out group health insurance for the first time when employee number two, five or ten arrives.

The foundation is already there.

Not Every One-Employee Employer Should Do This

I wouldn’t take this case to mean every business with one employee should immediately establish a group health plan.

Sometimes individual coverage makes more sense.

Sometimes an ICHRA may be worth considering.

Sometimes the economics simply don’t justify creating an employer-sponsored plan.

That’s why we evaluate the alternatives first.

But this employer had a reason to provide a meaningful benefit to an important employee. They explored their options, completed the underwriting process, joined the required organization, evaluated the plans and went through enrollment.

They went the distance.

A year later, the result is a good health plan, a relatively manageable first renewal and an established group health insurance arrangement capable of growing with them.

For one employee, that’s a pretty substantial accomplishment.

Sometimes being a very small employer doesn’t mean you need to duct-tape together a temporary solution. With the right circumstances and the willingness to do the work, you can build the real thing.

Client-identifying details have been omitted or generalized. Premiums have been rounded. Plan availability, eligibility, underwriting, benefits and rates vary by employer and are subject to current carrier and program requirements.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations, and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Talk With McCarthy Stevenot Agency

If your Ohio business has only a few employees and you are trying to determine whether group health insurance is available and practical, we can help you evaluate the realistic options and understand the trade-offs.

For some employers, that may include comparing traditional small-group coverage, MEWA options, an ICHRA or other approaches. If underwriting-sensitive options may be available, a health insurance prescreen can also help determine what is realistic before making a decision.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency to discuss your situation, or call 513-891-9888.

Related Resources

Disclaimer

Broker’s Desk is a series of observations from more than three decades of helping Ohio small businesses and their owners navigate health insurance. Some articles explain a process. Others tell the stories behind the work. Client-identifying details may be omitted or generalized to protect privacy. Plan availability, eligibility, underwriting, benefits and rates vary by employer and program. These articles are intended to help readers understand how experienced brokers think through real-world situations, not to suggest there is one right answer for every business or individual.

What Do You Do When There Is No Good Health Insurance Renewal Option?

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about what employers can do when there is no good health insurance renewal option

Sometimes there isn’t a better quote.

Ted Stevenot featured in a Broker’s Desk graphic about what employers can do when there is no good health insurance renewal option

That’s an uncomfortable place to begin a discussion about a health insurance renewal, but it is where we recently found ourselves with a client facing an unusually difficult renewal increase.

This wasn’t a case where we opened the renewal, saw a large increase and immediately started moving deductibles around.

We pulled it apart.

We looked at the group’s claims experience. We looked at the people and conditions that appeared to be driving the experience. We considered whether some of those claims might be behind us or whether they represented continuing risk. We looked at other carriers. We looked across the renewing carrier’s entire array of available plans. We considered different deductibles, copays and network structures. We considered HMO and EPO options. We considered whether an ICHRA might make sense. We even considered whether there was a reasonable way to separate classes of employees and use different approaches for different parts of the workforce.

The deeper we went, the clearer the problem became.

There wasn’t an easy way out.

The problem wasn’t a lack of health insurance renewal options. It was that none of the realistic options were good.

When a renewal gets everyone’s attention

This increase was large enough that people became involved in the discussion who normally don’t spend their time thinking about health insurance.

That’s understandable.

When employee benefits suddenly create a major financial problem for a business, owners and senior leadership naturally start asking questions.

  • Did we shop other carriers?
  • Did we really look at everything?
  • Where did these particular plan options come from?
  • Why did we choose these plans out of all the alternatives?
  • Could we look at another carrier someone had heard about?
  • Could we wait a few months and try again?

Those are good questions.

In fact, I think an employer facing an increase of this magnitude should ask them.

But answering them requires more than saying, “We shopped the market.”

It requires being able to explain what you did and why.

We tested the market. The market gave us an answer.

We approached the realistic carrier alternatives for this group.

Most were unwilling to quote the case competitively. The alternatives we received did not materially improve the renewal.

That wasn’t a solution.

It also meant we had very little negotiating leverage with the incumbent carrier. Had another credible carrier produced an attractive proposal, we might have been able to use it to push for some relief. Without a competitive alternative, there wasn’t much leverage to bring to that conversation.

One question that came up involved another carrier we hadn’t pursued.

There’s an important distinction here between being able to say you requested a quote from every carrier whose name appears on a list and actually conducting a responsible market review.

Not every carrier has meaningful penetration in every market. Network strength matters. Provider relationships matter. Contracted discounts matter. A carrier with very little local market presence may technically be an option without being an option we would be comfortable recommending.

We could have requested another quote simply so we could say we had done it.

But if we wouldn’t advise the client to take that option, what would that accomplish?

Shopping a health insurance case isn’t a box-checking exercise. The objective isn’t to produce the largest stack of proposals. It is to identify credible alternatives that we would actually be willing to put in front of the employer and its employees.

In this case, the credible market alternatives weren’t better.

A few better claims months don’t necessarily change the underlying problem

Another natural question was whether we should simply wait a few months and shop the case again.

We can certainly revisit a case.

But there is a problem with assuming that waiting a few months will automatically produce a different result.

In this case, we didn’t have the kind of detailed claims information a very large employer may have available. You can see enough to know that claims have been substantial. You may see that claims were particularly high during one period and then improved during another.

That can create an understandable sense that perhaps the group is getting better.

But paid claims looking better for several months doesn’t necessarily mean the underlying risk has disappeared.

There are really two views occurring at the same time.

  • There is the backward look: What claims has the plan already paid?
  • And there is the forward look: Based on the health conditions present in the group, medical trend and other underwriting factors, what might this population cost going forward?

Those aren’t necessarily the same thing.

A condition that generated significant claims last year may still exist even if it hasn’t generated a major claim during the last few months. From an underwriting perspective, the potential for future claims may remain.

That was an important part of this particular case.

We weren’t looking at a group where everything that had happened could simply be placed in the rearview mirror.

So “let’s try again in a few months” sounded more promising than it actually was.

Eventually you have to manage the trade-offs

Once we had worked through the alternatives, we were left with the renewing carrier and a difficult increase.

Now the question changed.

Instead of asking, How do we make the increase disappear?

We had to ask, How do we make the best of a bad situation?

The employer had been offering multiple medical plan choices.

We went back through the renewing carrier’s larger portfolio of available plans and pulled out the options we thought were most relevant. That selection wasn’t arbitrary. We were trying to find the best intersection of premium, deductible, out-of-pocket exposure, network access and the benefits employees actually use.

We ultimately recommended simplifying the plan structure and consolidating the existing choices into a single option.

You could think of it as meeting in the middle.

For some employees, the change meant greater out-of-pocket exposure. For others, it actually meant somewhat lower cost sharing. Because of how enrollment was distributed across the existing options, the change produced meaningful premium savings for the group.

Was it painless?

No.

More employees were moving toward greater cost sharing than were moving in the other direction. There is no point pretending otherwise.

But we also didn’t take the plan all the way to the bone.

We didn’t move everyone into the highest deductible available. We didn’t force the group into the narrowest network structure. We didn’t move to an HMO simply because it could reduce premium. And we didn’t create the disruption of abandoning the group plan entirely for an ICHRA.

Those possibilities were considered. We just didn’t think the situation required pushing that far.

There are times when benefit management is less about finding a perfect answer and more about knowing how far to turn each dial.

In the middle of reducing benefits, we found a place to add value

There was another part of this renewal that I think is worth mentioning.

The employer already offered some voluntary coverage, meaning employees who wanted those benefits could purchase them through the group without the employer having to absorb the premium.

During the process, we also found an opportunity to expand those voluntary benefits.

At first glance, “voluntary benefit” can sound like something that isn’t much of an employer benefit at all.

After all, the employer isn’t paying the premium.

But I don’t think that’s the right way to look at it.

An employer can create value simply by providing access.

Through a group arrangement, employees can have access to disability coverage, dental and vision plans, and benefit structures that may be difficult or impossible for them to duplicate efficiently in the individual market. Dental and vision plans can also provide access to established provider networks. In the case of dental coverage, for example, group plans can include meaningful annual benefits, strong networks and orthodontia options that an employee may have difficulty reproducing independently at a comparable cost.

The employer is already administering benefits and paying a bill to the carrier. Where good voluntary products are available, opening those options to employees can make sense even if the employer doesn’t contribute toward the premium.

In this case, I especially liked adding voluntary benefits because of everything else that was happening.

We were asking employees to absorb a more difficult medical benefit structure. At the same time, we found another place where we could improve the overall benefits package without adding meaningful employer cost.

That doesn’t erase a difficult medical renewal.

But when you’re managing a difficult situation, you look for every place where you can create value.

Sometimes the answer is simply the best answer available today

This case pressed us.

We care about what happens to the company and its employees. We didn’t want them to receive this renewal, and we certainly didn’t want to walk into the room and tell them there was nothing we could do.

So we kept asking ourselves the same question:

What else could we do?

  • We asked it while we were working on the case.
  • We asked it when management questioned our approach.
  • We asked it among ourselves afterward.
  • What did we miss?
  • What other carrier should we have approached?
  • What other funding arrangement should we have considered?
  • What other plan structure could have produced a better balance?

There is an important discipline in doing that. Experience shouldn’t make you defensive about your work. It should make you willing to challenge it.

If somebody has a better idea, I want to hear it.

But after going back through this case, I wouldn’t manufacture an alternative simply to make the process look more exhaustive. I wouldn’t recommend a carrier I didn’t believe was a responsible choice. I wouldn’t disrupt the entire benefits program just to demonstrate that we had done something dramatic.

Sometimes professional judgment means being able to say: We looked. This is where the facts led us.

And we’re not done

There is one more thing I want this employer to understand.

This recommendation isn’t a declaration that these should be their benefits forever.

It is our recommendation for what they should do now.

We will revisit it.

If the group’s circumstances improve, we will look for opportunities to improve benefits. We will look at the market again. We will reconsider carriers. We will reconsider plan structures. We will reconsider funding arrangements. If circumstances eventually make an ICHRA or another approach appropriate, we’ll look seriously at that too.

And if the next renewal is difficult again, we still have additional levers available that we deliberately chose not to pull this time.

That matters.

When an employer is facing a difficult renewal, I don’t think the objective should simply be to survive the meeting, place the coverage and move on.

The objective is to make the best decision available today while remaining vigilant for the next opportunity to make things better.

There are renewals where a broker finds a substantially better carrier and everybody walks away happy.

There are renewals where negotiation produces meaningful savings.

And then there are renewals like this one.

The market has spoken. The claims are real. The alternatives aren’t better. There is no rabbit to pull out of the hat.

That’s when the work becomes less visible but perhaps more important.

You pull the renewal apart. You test your assumptions. You challenge your own recommendations. You explain the trade-offs. You protect the things worth protecting. You make concessions where they produce the most value. You look elsewhere in the benefit package for opportunities to improve something. And you preserve options for the future.

A broker’s value isn’t demonstrated only by finding a cheaper quote.

Sometimes there isn’t one.

Sometimes the value is knowing what to do next.

About the Author

For more than three decades, Ted Stevenot has helped Ohio small businesses and their owners evaluate health insurance and employee benefits as a partner at McCarthy Stevenot Agency, Inc.

He writes the Broker’s Desk series to document the real-world decisions, conversations, and observations that come from helping small businesses navigate health insurance.

Talk With McCarthy Stevenot Agency

If your Ohio business is facing a difficult health insurance renewal, we can help you review the renewal, evaluate realistic alternatives and understand the trade-offs before you make a decision.

Contact McCarthy Stevenot Agency to discuss your situation, or call 513-891-9888.

Related resources

Disclaimer

Broker’s Desk is a series of observations from more than three decades of helping Ohio small businesses and their owners navigate health insurance. Some articles explain a process. Others tell the stories behind the work. All are intended to help readers understand how experienced brokers think through real-world situations, not to suggest there is one right answer for every business or individual.